Is Manny Pacquiao the GOAT

Your list is as real as you being a trainer , Nelson being your uncle and vampires being real.

 

Filipino boxer? Yes. But that’s about it.

 

No

Ray Robinson is the GOAT, manny or anyone from his era isn't close

 

no way , hes marquez son

 

he is not even the best fighter of his generation, who is mayweather. So no.

 

Just mentioning Manny for a change instead of Floyd got all the Lovers here mad mad

 

I dont buy the 8 division thing. not where catchweights are involved and the JMM superfeather title was a defeat too. Floyd did catchweights too and I dont rate them either. Pac is great but a very manufactured career and a massive question mark about PEDS too. IJust my opinion though. Floyd beats him at any points in their respective careers imo

 

Lol def not. But he is definitely up there.

 

Rags to Riches
Slumdog to Congressman to Senator

 

Amazing fighter and deserves a place in top 20 of all time. But greatest? No.

Greatest of last 30 years - arguably. It’s either Pac or Mayweather. Really comes down to personal preference.

 

Eeeew! No way, fllo's voted for Marcos. Shows Pacquiao's losing fans after his politics.

 

Not a chance in hell. One of the greatest of all time? Of course he is...which is a huge compliment and massive achievement, but anybody that knows boxing before the 90s will know that he can't realistically be the GOAT.

 

No. Look at it this way. I can't say he is the GOAT of any individual weight class that he campaigned at. If you aren't in the argument for individual classes, how can you be in the argument overall?

He's definitely an ATG...........but greatest? Let's be honest, everyone knows that Sugar Ray Robinson is the GOAT.

That will never change. No fighter will ever have a career that even remotely approaches what he did.

/Thread

 

Your opinion is trash.