is Mayweather the Greatest of all time ? why or why not?

His career aint over.... so when its over, +10 years bring **** like that up........

 

I'll take Floyds' 15 best wins over Jones' any day.

 

exactly what i was gonna say

 

This content is protected

 

right now top 20 for sure, if he wins his next few fights easily top 10...but i feel the only way i would rank him at the GOAT right now if he would have fought people at certain times to prove he is the best...he just fights who he wants and has a good feeling he can win...not what the boxing world wants to see...

lets be realistic...two/three years ago he fights pac and takes a couple other fights we wanted to see...i could see him in talks of being the GOAT but that isn't the case

he beats canelo and continues to dominate the sport like he has been overall...i could say top 5 ATG for sure

 

He's not even the greatest of this era.

 

This content is protected

It's worth pointing out Hopkins had more than 100 amateur fights IIRC.

 

Yeah.

Pea, Roy, JCC. Feels like we've already done this.

 

Just about cracks the top 50 for me.

While he does have a good resume it could have been so much better but his opponent selection over the last six years pushes him further down the list than his talent probably deserves.

 

Lemme borrow some vcash

 

:deal

Big O a G.

 

In which he was 67 years old.

 

:yep

Love Hops, but IMO there was a reason he didn't move up to 175 until Roy was finally stopped.

 

Man, I barely started. :verysad. First mistake was betting GR Jr to take care of the under.