is Mayweather the Greatest of all time ? why or why not?

none of the undefeated fighters do too well in these lists, if your fighting lots of tough fights your gonna loose some.

 

:twisted:



Ketchel is too damned high.

 

floyd makes great fighters look average, 43 have tried 43 have failed.

 

No, because he isn't Sugar Ray Robinson.

 

Exactly. If he had met Oscar or Mosley during their lightweight runs, Mayweather wouldn't have gotten by them. Pernell whitaker beats Mayweather also.
As for Pac, i do believe Floyd beats him relatively easy.

 

:deal

 

Woah woah woah, chill down people. No need to get upset when someone claims they believe one fighter is better than another fight. It's highly subjective.

Clearly Jones top couple wins are better than Floyds'. But I'll value Floyds' depth over Jones' for sure.

Mayweather top 15 wins:
Corrales
Castillo X2
Genaro
Cotto
Hatton
Oscar
Mosley
JMM
Baldomir
Judah
Gatti
Manfredy
Chavez
Ortiz

Roy's best 15 wins:
Toney
Hopkins
Tarver I
Hill
Ruiz
McCallum
Griffin II
Woods
Del Valle
Paz
Harding
Johnson
Gonzalez
Lucas
Grant

I think I could have fun by listing their 10 worst performances/opponents.

 

The thing I like about Floyd though he would be one of the only ones that would fit in with the old school era, especially at 130, 135.

 

if victor ortiz(and 40 others) is a great fighter i should stick to being sarcastic about footballers in the lounge

 

Marciano ahead of Ricardo...?

I think Ricardo is a top 50 ATG, you say 110 range... Hmm...

 

not like that ***** in your avatar.

 

marciano should not be mentioned in the same sentence as mayweather.

 

Post your thoughts on Lopez in Classic please :happy

 

This content is protected

12/12/1912.

Was born to do triples.