Is Miguel Cotto past his best?

No, he's absolutely in his prime. 2 severe beatdowns don't mean nothing.

 

Cotto was shot and destroyed when pac fought hin and is now prime, thats flogic though.
In reality he is slightly past prime but still very good.

 

Give me an example of this?

 

Exactly. If Floyd fought him now at 154 and beat him convincingly that'd be an EXCELLENT win.

 

here comes another hater to discredit a Floyd fight. Cotto is not in his prime but he sure as hell still an elite fighter and not close to being shot. Floyd isnt in his prime either. matter of fact Cotto has a 5 year age advantage on floyd. and btw Floyd has NEVER ducked Cotto. Cotto hasnt ever shown interest in fighting floyd. back in 05' a Floyd fight was offered to Cotto and he turned it cuz his team didnt think he was ready. technically if any has ducked it was Cotto, but of course people like to blame the undefeated guy like always

 

How do you duck someone who doesn't even call you out to fight.atsch

 

He's seen better days but he's still very good. The Mayweather fight has come a few years too late, but it's still a good fight.

 

he lost some and picked up some. overall, would say, slightly past his best but still would give anyone a good fight.

 

why wont you go make some threads about how excited you are over dimitrenko and pulev you ****?

 

Yes he is. Why? Because you are asking ESB. The place where if you are a pro boxer and you lose a fight you are shot, past prime, or a hypejob. If you are potential mayweather opponent or PAC opponent you are no good either. Especially if it's mayweather. Threads will begin to pop up prematurely to start discrediting rumored opponents.

 

What he may have given up in offensive sharpness, durability, and willingness to engage he has compensated for with newly reinforced fundamentals and strategic skills. Whether that would work for him against someone like Floyd has yet to be seen.

He may, with the right mental and physical preparation, be able to get the best of both worlds and recapture the hungriness in the ring to go along with his sharpened skill-set.

 

Floyd "retired" for the almost 2 years Cotto was on top in the WW division. I think this is a good fight, but let's not rewrite history here. Cotto has since then taken two brutal beatings. It's not the same as if they had squared off in 2007-8.

 

What sharpened skills do you speak of? Cotto was pretty much a finished product technically against Pac. About as fundamentally sound as anyone in boxing.

 

Agreed with all of the above. If no Pacquiao vs Mayweather, I'll take this as the consolation prize.