Is Oscar an Atg or just HoF

I gotta agree with anyone who has him in the top 50 range. I Think anything outside of fifty kinda diminishes ATG lists but I think he is in the cut barely. But for anyone to rank him higher than that has to be realistic @ 147 he should be in the top 15, you have to put at least SRR, SRL, Hearns, Griffith, Duran, Basillo, Pernell, Napolles, Gavilan, Basillo, Armstrong, Walker Benitez above him and arguably, Tito, PBF and Pac (who at the end of the day will be looked upon more favourably over time)

 

Absolutely.

Quick example, his victories over Hernandez and Gatti are considered throwaway wins for DLH but huge victories for FLoyd:deal

 

According to who? You? There's no cut-off for it. There's not even a definition for it, lol.

But if we're just splitting hairs, I'll just say that among the 100 greatest fighters of all time, he's somewhere in the top of the fourth quartile.

 

:good He always has...Strange phenomenom.

 

Wow you really have issues.

It is called ad hominem. Look it up. For an admin you are really thin skinned and immature.

What does Pac's rating have to do with anything? So you do constantly measure ODLH achievement versus PBF and Pac? That does not bode well for you or ODLH.

It is like arguing with a freshman kid in high school here.

 

Oh ****, my bad...Just keep clicking on the Pinoy advert banners..Please. Thank you, come again.:thumbsup

 

yea but he didnt beat tito

 

The reason I like the Mayorga fight is because of the build up , not because of what actually went on in the ring.

Im done with you , you dont offer me anything .

Your intellect is clearly a level below mine.

 

It's irritating that we have *******s like you, who can't get Pac's balls out your mouths, and trash and belittle legends..You tards have been doing it for years...I've been patient as I need you Pinoys to click on the Pinoy Advertising banners..Please click.

 

What the **** are you talking about???

Everything to you is *******s and Pinoy and ****. Pac is not even in my top 10 fav boxers (most of mine are pre 2000 fighters).
Did a Pinoy midget **** you or a family member or ate your dog or something.
I am not even a Pinoy.

Where did I insult ODLH? Are you illiterate or stupid or both?
Like I said, it is like arguing with a prepubescent kid here. Apperantly, disagreeing with your opinion is a form of an insult and justification for web rage. Good job.

Pinoy advert??? The Norton Antivirus and Toyota ads?

WTF! Step away from they keyboard for 15 minutes muchacho.

 

Seriously, you have no idea what Pac and Floyd's atg ratings have to do with this conversation

 

You miss the point. While it is essential to know ODLH contemporaries and quasi-temporaries to properly create a viable top 50 list, it is his constant and silly fixation with Pac (and less degree PBF) that is absurd.
The list is top 50 (or 100), not top 3.

 

NO my friend YOU missed the point.

When discussing ATG rankings, it is good to use the poster's opinion on some of the subject's contemporaries as a credibility test.

 

I stopped reading after I saw where ali, marciano and dempsey are rated

 

Yes, that is what I said in the postt you just quoted....atsch