Is Roy Jones Jr. The Greatest Super-Middleweight Ever?

The is no doubt about it for me, Calzaghe has defined the divison.

 

why? he said exactly what mde sense....but as you are called jonesjrp4p i see ALOT of biased

 

who has he beat besides jeff lacy? and thats such an accomplishment

 

thank you at last somone who hasnt got an anti calzaghe thing on their mind

your a rare poster china you pick calzaghe over anyone but give all the right details to why he is the greatest super middlewieght and maybe best british middlewieght of all time

 

Man, why can people never just express different opinions on this board? It always comes down to denigrating someone else's character if they disagree. Anyway, RJJ I think was definitely the best p4p of SMWs, but as CHJoe said, JC has done more in the division. I mean who did Roy really fight at 168? Toney and... Pazienza? P4Per=Roy, done more at 168=JC.

 

toney is a way better name then lacy

 

Calzaghe is the greatest SMW ever on accomplishment. Jones is better h2h and p4p.

 

Agreed, but that was one of only like 6 or 7 fights at SMW for RJJ. I don't think that JC is really fighting stellar opponents all the time, but 20 title defenses is 20 title defenses, right? Maybe you guys disagree, but I think that's pretty impressive whomever you're fighting.

 

Jones had 12 fights at 168. He only had 5-6 championship ones.

 

Even today I suspect Calzaghe would struggle to KO Jones, so back when Jones was at his best there's no way that would happen. Prime Jones has better EVERYTHING than Calzaghe, how the **** can you win a fight where you have no advantages???

Oh sorry, Joe slaps harder than Roy - I forgot :nut

 

I don't think he could beat Wlad at heavyweight, though even I might be wrong about something one day?

 

robin reid ,mark deleney,chris eubank,evens ashira,charles brewer,byron motchel....he fought 8 world champions all but 4 not having a area belt on the resume.



so what if some never go past certain places in boxing he fought pro boxers who were there to fight not for a pay cheque

 

you know what i mean:nono

 

atsch