Is Sergio Martinez Over rated?

. Beat willaims twice in my books and that ko in the second fight will be talked about for 50 years .Koed cintron in my books. Beat up pavilk. Dominated his last fight. Amazing boxing skills. I think he can cause any 168lb fight troubles and beat alot of them. He would beat any 154lb out there

He is underated.

 

:deal He was under the radar for a long time. He's finally getting credit!

 

He's awesome, entertaining, fights the best, and is DEAD SEXY

 

he hasn't fought any hof locks or atgs

you have to wonder how his skills would look and hold up against more skilled competition

 

Underated should be the answer... I honestly wouldnt mind and not throw a tantrum if they had him as the P4P king instead of what most other places have him behind Floyd and Manny...

 

And he comes in killer shape and is the stud of boxing

 

this is actually why i'm kinda torn.

He flew under the radar for a while but his best wins are against Pavlik (who i remember people deriding as 1 dimensional, especially after Hopkins beat him) and Williams who I think may have actually been a little overrated but he did have a hard time getting big fights.

The other problem is the division he's fighting in is fairly weak.

 

this is what I mean:thumbsup

 

Definitely overrated by those who think he's already a great Middleweight champion.

Martinez is a pretty good fighter with solid skills, but he is just starting to create his legacy.

 

:yep

 

The way he is beating his opponents also should be taken in consideration. People are now saying Williams was overated, but lets be realistic that KO was very impressive a guy in his prime to get drop like that. He gave Pavlik a beating in his weight class and took both of his titles. Say what you want about Pavlik but the guy was doing his thing in his weight class where he belong and had wins over the tough Rubio. He then face undefeated Dzinziruk though at higher weight class and stop him for the first time in his career. The guy is beating guys convincingly with no demands and controversies who are in the top of their divisions or belt holders simple as that...

 

He's not overrated for active fighters, but when people make threads comparing him to Hagler an Monzon it's ****ing laughable.

 

:good

 

The guy landed a lucky punch and now became a star... LOL never fought any HOF or ATG fighters. overrated defenitely.