Is Shane Mosley overrated?

Again, no credit given to Mosely. He didn't have to move up 2 classes and fight the best without settling into the division first. Don't exagerate the situation to suit your agenda.

 

mosley is the better fighter, period.

 

So you didn't mean that he has always been overated?

Then why downgrade his accomplishment against DLH? Whats the purpsose? Seemed to me that was a part of the equation of his being overated.

 

This isn't what you said though. Your first post gave no credit whatsoever, thats why I called you on it.

 

I don't think Shane is overated. The last few years I think age has been a bit of a factor, when he was at his peak though, what a hell of a fighter he was....and still is. I was impressed with him in his loss against Cotto, he got hit &pushed around a lot, and stayed in there against the younger, stronger man. I've always been a big Mosley fan.

 

Let PBF roll trough that list and see if he would still be undefetaed
Mosely 1st Ballet HOF

 

I took his post to mean PBF fighting all those fighters in the context that Mosely did- not fighting them now.

Floyd would not beat Winky.

 

JulieJulie is just an oscarsexual fruit, dont take no notice.

 

yes mosley is overrated.His performance against de la hoya in 2000 was breathtaking,but i have been dissapointed with what he has done since,he beat vargas,collazo and de la hoya again (robbery)

 

I Still Think He Is The Best Floyd Challenge Out There. Styles Make Fights.