Is Vic Darchinyan a top 100 ATG?

It's a bad analogy, actually. That guy implied that because Frazier had a losing record against top fighters and got in, then Vic could do the same, completely overlooking the vast significance of Frazier's best win as compared to Vic's, ie overlooking the difference between them that actually matters.

It does seem like I'm dealing with some pretty thick individuals on this thread. It's a shame we'll need to wait a few years for me to be proved right and you guys to be proved dead wrong.

:smoke

 

I'm getting bored of this. My response to you is the same as to that last chump:

Hopefully Vic rematches Donaire or Agbeko soon, we can discuss this matter again after that happens.

Deal?

 

Yeah. General Forum humour is the best... :dead

 

If Tszyu made HOF, Vic should. Vic has done the same maybe even more, has been more active and didn't stick to 1 weight class

 

Yes to the HOF

No to top 100

 

I don't think you think like you think you do.

 

Yeah, that's really interesting. A guy can't have looked good in his fights in the ring if he had apparently said to people he was considering quitting. Those two things are directly related. Great point.

 

This is tiresome, I agree.

Ultimately, my analogy made the point I wanted it quite succinctly.

And Vic, at this stage, is not HOF material IMO.

Unless he rematches and beats guys like Donaire, Mares and Agbeko.

Which he won't. And I think I'm ready to move on to another thread now. We'll see. :good

 

More hilarity. I've definitely found the joker in the pack here. Laugh? I nearly started.

 

I'd agree he has the best chance against Mares. That's a fight he could win. I also wouldn't favour him at all against Agbeko and Donaire. I actually think Agbeko beats him more convincingly in a rematch. Either way, I put a lot of stock into wins over prime, top fighters, and for me one excellent win over Mijares and a TD over Perez just doesn't cut the mustard at all when it comes to HOF calibre achievements. JMHO.

 

You evidently weren't aware of Donaire until he hit the big time. You should track down some of his old fights. I won't say anything else as I'm not on this forum to ***** and argue. Contrary to what you might think, I actually really like watching Vic Darchinyan... but to me that's a different thing entirely from evaluating whether someone merits HOF inclusion. JMO.

 

So what's your opinion on Khaosai Galaxy?

 

He should be around 100th lower from where Gatti is being ranked.