Is Vic Darchinyan top ten pound for pound

Still very confusing, if you rank him in top 10 list, where then you'll place Donaire who won an Upset and KO of the year against him?

 

Donaire hasn't accomplished what Darchinyan has since their fight.

 

vic cracked my top 10 p4p after destroying mijares.

so yeah

 

9 or 10

 

but you cannot rank Vic above Nonito, are you?

 

not yet, but top 10 for sure

 

Anyone who doesn't have Vic in their Top 10 is stupid.

He should have already been in everyone's P4P Top 10 after the Mijares win. When you beat a P4P fighter you become a P4P fighter yourself. Hatton entered straight in after beating Zoo, Margarito did after beating Cotto, and Mosley did after beating Margarito.
Why is there double standards for Vic??

And the Ring ratings are a frigging JOKE, I hope people don't take this seriously. It's not a frigging popularity contest for ****s sake. . . .

 

He's in the top 10 PFP for sure now, why wouldn't he be?

 

No IMO

 

Yes, I can, objectively. And I love Donaire and despise Darchinyan.

 

lopez>VD

 

That is a FACTgood

 

Vic should be in top 10 now that he has unified the superfly but he will still be KOd Donaire.

 

cotto and lopez and margarito is better than VD

 

He cracks my top 15 but is outside of my top 12.