Is Winky currently one of the best 15 fighters in the world? If so, why?

Spinks is your #15 :good

 

Spinks gets knocked the **** out, comes back and wins a majority decision over Karmazin, beats some nobody, then moves up and loses yet you still put him in your top 15????

 

spinks in a top 15 p4p is carzy

 

Dawg KO1 Decebal :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl

 

Winky's going to move down to 160 and stop everybody on accumulation!:smoke

 

Good post. :good

I only disagree about your analysis of the Hopkins fight. Winky was schooled in that one. It wasn't close IMO. But everything else i agree with. I don't think his performance against Hopkins is a good indicator of where he's at.

 

You gotta beat other p4p fighters ranked higher than you or win titles in different weight classes to move up in p4p rankings. I think you even agreed with me about that point, Decebal. So why in God's name would you put a guy like Arthur Abraham on here, when he has NEVER faced anyone even in the top 20 p4p and has fought at MW his whole career, fighting tomato cans no less..

 

Wright was P4P#3 at most experts' list last year, before he fought P4Per Hopkins. He fought Hopkins 3 weight classes higher than his natural weight (LMW) and 2 classes higher than his highest ever.

Ha lost that fight only by 1 point at most experts' cards, some had a draw, others had him winning.

Why wouldn't he be in the top10?

 

winky white the gbp coffee boy hasn't done **** since beating tito and one of his bosses 3 or 4 years ago.

maybe we should put castillo in the top 15 for beating corrales and casamayor 3 years ago?

 

I can't agree with Winky's being rated so highly still.

 

That's the thing right there. All of Wink's accomplishments are from days long gone. He hasn't done **** of note in a long while.