Sharkey was tiny by the standards of Povetkin's era and he had no equalizer. And his skills, both offensive and certainly defensive, were not up to Sasha's. This would be target practice in the truest send of the term. I see a devastating KO in under 7.
I don’t think the Schmeling fights are the best example of technical displays by Sharkey, who at his peak is a great infighter and utilized more head movement than any other heavyweight form the period. Honestly that footage might be the clunkiest I’ve seen Jack, maybe you can use the argument that he looked so clunky because Schmeling was his most difficult opponent but he doesn’t really display his usual shiftiness or movement even when Max isn’t really doing anything. I think these give the best idea as to Sharkey’s movement and head movement: This content is protected This content is protected This content is protected This content is protected One of his better infighting displays, against a fighter who imo is substantially superior to Max as a technician in Loughran: https://youtu.be/ycRC6h0N1OU?si=3YMZXrn6sdByFaaL
Not saying that he beats Povetkin, but Sharkey does look a deal better than in the vid against Schmeling in those videos.
I disagree, in the other videos Sharkey is utilizing much more head movement and more overall versatility with regard to his footwork and punch variety. His footwork and balance are his weakest attributes but constantly shifting and level changing does make up for it which he isn’t doing much of against Schmeling. That’s just my perspective though.
He damn near falls down when throwing a right hand. Sasha would groove an uppercut that would end matters hastily the second time Sharkey attempted such a maneuver.
I don't think you know how good Sharkey was.. he wasn't just a jab.. his problem was he just wasn't consistent enough.. but he's better than Povetkin: This content is protected
Sharkey’s right is nowhere near the calibre of his left but he does also seem to know the risks when throwing his right hand as well considering how he moves his head, or closes distance for a clinch, or steps out of range immediately after throwing them. He also seems to know when the appropriate time is to throw and time it and has confidence to get out of the way in time. Not the first nor the last time a world class fighter got away with throwing less than stellar punches with the knowledge and speed to get away in time in case it went south, and that’s not even taking into account when Sharkey threw solid short right hands on counters where he wouldn’t lose his balance. Sharkey is many things but I wouldn’t call predictable one of them; he varied between erratic left hooks and rights to short and well timed ones. An erratic fighter I also heard that Jack’s right hand was compromised early in his career due to a hand injury though I haven’t seen proof for that.
H2H no but I think you can make a case for Sharkey if they were the same size or in terms of more skill for my 0.2$ Povetkin mulches him in real life though IMO.
Pretty much and Povetkin didn’t fight like a 220- 225lbs guy from Sharkey’s time like Liston for example at 210lbs seemed like he carried too much weight for his frame… he was lumbering where as Povetkin is a tight and relatively quick fighter for his size.
Jack Sharkey vs. Primo Carnera 1 is very interesting for this thread. I do not believe Jack Sharkey AND Primo Carnera, at their best, were as unskilled as many seem to think.