James Toney the greatest Super Middle of all time as of now??

lol toney's not the one with 44 fights at super middle. Tony Thornton gave Eubank a very tough fight and was a good win for Toney. Thornton had Eubank running the whole 12th round of their fight. Durham was a ****ing cruiserweight fight. Ricky Thomas beat Darrin Van Horn and went 10 rounds with Lamar Parks before facing Toney. damnit boxrec

 

:rofl

 

A prime Toney still wouldn't beat a Prime Jones Jr at 168 even if he wasn't weight drained, but I would favor Toney over everybody else. Ward, Bute, Froch, Calzaghe, none of those guys would have been able to deal with the slickness and counter punching of a prime Toney at 168.

 

Jones/Calzaghe.
Since they didnt fight each other I give it as a tie.

What is Toneys best win?
Jirov?

 

Lol.

So it's a duck when some fighter calls out some other fighter? You cannot be serious man. How many guys has Mayweather and Pacquiao ducked then?

LMAO. You are a tool.

 

i am a massive toney fan but he got his arse handed to him by rrj i cant watch that fight. and so what if he was weight drained that his own fault for being lazy and ill prepared. he who fails to prepare is the man that is prepared to fail.
but if you go off skills wise yes he is up there but on resume he is not

 

^this

 

Ottke's resume @ 168 is pretty much awash w/ Calzaghe's. Or close at least. Doesn't say much does it.

 

Crazy that Roy Jones beat this man so effortlessly!

 

:-verysadatsch

 

if you're talking about Toney's best win at any weight, it would be McCallum, you idiot :rofl

 

Ward will be the greatest SMW when it is all said and done.

 

Don't expect some wannabe chin expert to know too much. Just go back to watching tapes of guys getting KO'd, then braggin how smart you are.

Or, do a resume comparison, make use of that so-called knowledge...:deal

 

Calzaghe is a *****.