the only way this fight could happen is if Hopkins moves up to heavyweight. I highly doubt Toney can ever make Cruiser weight again.
Hopkins would have beaten Toney at any point in their respective careers, and would do so at Cruiserweight. Furthermore, Toney will never see that weight again in his lifetime.
Toney would have beaten up Borenard at any weight, and in any era. James Toney at HW will knock out crybaby Hopkins. And at cruiser as well. Hopkins does not have the frame for HW.. He doesnt have the muscle to make HW. He is a smaller man than James Toney in more ways than one.