Roy Jones would beat James Toney up bad now, he would probably stop him. James Toney is in a bad way physically and psychologically.
Competition-wise I agree with you. It's probably a fairly close match-up provided Toney comes less the spare tyre he's been wearing around his waist, and make no mistake, if Browne KOs him it will make Lucas Browne news. Not sure I agree with the 'grown man he can make his own decisions' part though. At some point in time, hopefully in the near future, boxing needs to start growing a conscience and find a way to stop aimless journeymen destroying their health and futures for a few measly dollars.