James Toneys greatest wins: Rank them

Yeah he came to fight against Toney and the ending was probably one of the most spectacular Ko's Ive ever seen. Williams crumbled like a building.

 

That could certainly be argued a win for Toney, though I wouldn't agree. I had McCallum winning by a point and thought a draw was a fair decision.

It depends very much on how much weight you give Toney's power punching in comparison too McCallums more consistent work behind the jab. Terefore I can see this fight being scored in different ways. But those who think Toney won clearly should also have Norton winning against Holmes.

For me this was a very close fight with no clear winner. A draw and a rematch was the right thing imo. If only that rematch had been scored even close to correctly...

 

toney-littles fights was crazy to me..tim was very close to becoming the first man to stop toney...toney had some bad cuts and the doctor was only giving him one more round...so toney threw all that boxing **** out the window..went out like a man possessed and obliterated tim in the 4th round..good stuff

 

Toney was hurt very badly against Reggie Johnson, which is crazy because he seemed to have an iron chin as he moved up in weight, fighting some of the biggest punchers. Toney killed himself to make weight and that probably factored into him getting hit and hurt more at the lower weights.

 

yeah that tiberi fight was a good example of the weight draining he was doing...at the end of that fight is toney is absolutely reeling ready to pass out

 

yeah 217lb toney that fought holyfield is a problem for any heavyweight right now because of his style.

 

I wasn't thinking. I thought those 5 were the only options.

 

1. Michael Nunn
2. Mike McCallum
3. Iran Barkley
4.Reggie Johnson
5. Vasilliy Jirov
6. Evander Holyfield
7. Charles Williams
8. Tim Littles
9. Tony Thornton
10. Merqui Sosa