Jermell Charlo isn't even close to a Top 10 P4P ranking.

He just became undisputed in one of 2-3 divisions where everyone in the top 15 has fought each other. There are no ducks in that division. Look how Canelo just became undisputed in a division where none of the top guys fought each other so who knows who could have beaten who The top 5 was Canelo, Smith, BJS, Plant, Benavidez. The only person to fight any of the other 4 was Canelo.

Put some respect on the 154 division that has giving excellent a matches in the last 3 years vs a division where the other top guys last opponents were Truax & Feigenbutz, Murray & Coceres, Njikam & Ryder, and Ellis & Kyrone Davis.

 

Well said.

 

I think he belongs in it more than Taylor does.

 

He probably gets into the top ten because to make a top ten list you need ten bodies and that's a tall order since 2020.

This is why I've said we should go to a top five or even top three until we see more fighters distinguish themselves.

 

No **** yet the thread starter had taylor in the top 10 p4p yet wants to talk about agendas.

 

The guy just unified. He in the very list deserves consideration.

 

Its not Rediculous at all actually and he's not 4-2. He had one loss and a draw out of those 6 fights And avenged them both in devastating fashion. Give the man his just due. He just unified the division, the first person in 154lb history to do so and only the 7th in the 4belt era. In my opinion he could easily bump out Callum Smith and even Beterbiev. "A" lost is not the end all be all when you have been running the gauntlet within a division. Many people let their emotions get the best of them when it comes to cocky fighters such as him and ignore their accomplishments and skills in the ring and Yes he does have skills he just fell in love with his Power over the las t few years.

 

What's wrong with that he was a deserved top 10 fighter.. the guy earned it… he unified his division in more impressive fashion than Charlo did.. Charlo won the WBC off a guy who was knocked out by Andy Lee, defended that a bunch of times including a gift against the smaller Trout, then got his arse boxed off by Harrison who no one rated, lost it.. got it back then unified with the WBA and IBF against Rosario (which was a good win admittedly) & then drew with Castano in what was seen as another gift.. he then unified.. Also let's be honest he was a iffy rising up the ranks as well because many thought the likes of Vanes beat him too.. Taylor looked **** last time but in his overall career he has been more impressive .. it's questionable NOW whether he deserves to be in after his last performance but if someone HAD him top 10 then there was nothing unusual about it because most people did. Stop playing the race card you fat ****.. its almost as bad as your callout videos & phony ass online gangsta persona .. you're middle-aged mate, grow up

BTW, Charlo has 37 fights & has been pro since 07.. Taylor has half that amount of fights & turned pro in 2015.. now do you see how silly you mocking that guy for having Taylor in the list is? Literally after six years as a professional he was undisputed, it took Charlo 15..

You're welcome.

 

He was on your p4p list before the jack fight. You want to say charlo lost twice but Taylor arguably lost twice to jack and prograis. It's not like 140 is any better than 154.

 

Ironic you say that considering he’s KO’d 3 guys in the current Ring Top 10. Not to mention when he beat Rosario, Trout, Martirosyan and Rosado when they were in the Ring top 10.