"Jim J. Jeffries vs. Max Baer" (Heavyweight Title Dream Fight.) Who is the man?

It would have been a war, though I'm not sure if I'd favour a KO here either way. Baer could punch but Jeffries could take it. Jeffries's own power against 210+ lb men is rightfully questionable. Baer could get the better of it for 10 rounds and even 15 rounds when in his best shape but otherwise Jeffries's stamina would win it for him.

 

My guess is that Baer has the better skills overall, and Jeff has an advantage in the clinches... Both went 20 rounds, so I don't believe Jeff has a real advantage in the stamina department.

Jeff clinches and mauls, wings big punches and generally isn't as effective as Baer's offense or defense.

Baer W15 Jeffries

 

I like Jeffries in this one......He was the better fighter in my opinion.....
Although Baer certainly had the power to hurt anybody Jim was tough as nails and he could punch like hell too......

And Jeffries had a great underrated head movement as he showed in this video.....2:09
[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CauVMvNspIY&feature=related[/ame]
It is tough to say without more footage on Jeffries, but maybe he was the more skilled fighter, I think........

 

I believe Baer would win if he came to the fight seriously.

 

The only film we have of a prime Jeffries in actual combat does NOT show him to use head movement or footspeed he plods after Ruhlin left hand cocked and held low,against Sharkey, he waits for Sharkey to attack,then counters.
I think both men had holes in their defences you could drive a bus through. A 39 year old Fitz coming out of retirement smashed Jeffries face to bits for 8 rds until his hands were smashed from the continuous impact of colliding with Jeffries bony head.
Baer was easily jabbed off by Braddock ,and Louis took him apart when he froze.
Jeffries low left hand would be an invitation for Baer to launch his overhand right,but Jeffries did tuck his chin down into his shoulder effectively.
I give Baer the power edge and his chin is proven against big heavyweights.
We have to take Jeffries chin on trust but ,assuming it holds up, durability is about equal, imo.
Baer suffered from bad hands and he could get them smashed here if Jeffries can take that right.
I think Baer has some early success battering Jeffries ,but I see Jeffries coming on late to take a close decision , after weathering the early storm, with no knockdowns scored by either man.

 

My heart goes out to Jeffries if he has become this woefully underapreciated!

 

Baer knocks him out or Jeffries outworks him for a decision is the most likely scenarios here

 

Baer is over rated, and didn't have the right heart for the game. Jeffries is better at almost eveything except the right hand. Jeffries via UD or late TKO.

 

Agreed ! While Max would survive far longer against Jim than a fast starting Tyson I believe Jeffries was classes above him and would pound out a clear victory ...

 

I don't find Jeffries the least bit impressive on film, he was big and strong sure but he had no technique, plodded and kept his hands very low. His entire modus operandi was to let his opponent smash him in the face then lunge at his opponent, wrestle and hit them in clinches. Baer's power and chin are VASTLY more proven than jeffries who faced super middles for practically his entire career. Baer takes this by KO bigger, better, harder hitting, more durable with stamina to go 20 rounds.