JMM VS Castillo

Well... to be fair, a prime Castillo would've defeated JMM, I have no doubts about that. JLC is a natural LW, JMM is a natural FW. In his prime Castillo was a very strong physical force, gave two very tough fights to Floyd, had a great great chin, good stamina, very decent power and good pressure style - too much for JMM at 135 IMO, he's really a 126.

 

very true in his prime at lightweight he was a monster

 

Jose Luis Castill would have given Juan Manuel a real beating,prolly stop him

 

He did but i think to be fair Casa was as good as him (JLC vs Casa close fight) and great great chin to:good

 

Yep and to think where there careers are and actually Marquez is a few months older

 

yeah but JMM didn't beat a prime Casa, just one that wasn't totally shot. JMM doesn't really belong imho at 135. He chased Manny to 130 and then to 135 and really could probably still be fighting at FW.

 

Good call. Would of been a great fight. I'd take Castillo via stoppage.

 

marquez is the greater fighter of the two.

 

If only we had a time machine.

 

Castillo stops him like he did Julio Diaz.

 

Castillo isnt just a brawler. He is a smart pressure fighter, who would not give as many countering chances to JMM as a lot of people might think.

I think he beats Marquez up for a wide decision.

 

Dont compare JMM with Julio Diaz.:nono

 

Castillo by KO