Joe Calzaghe, among top 25 Super Middleweight in boxing history?!

fair assessment:good who'd you put ahead H2H?

 

Never been a beast of a division? Then why was the weight class chosen for the super six tourno?

You ****

 

he is in the top 1.

 

He certainly should. I can't see anybody, even his most steadfast haters, saying he doesn't belong in the top 25 SMW's.

 

no just i have him 26th lol

of course he is he is number one by accomplishments he could lose to RJJ at smw both at their best maybe Toney but thats about it!IMO

 

Agree completely!

 

agreed brother...

 

were in the hec is darrin the school boy van horn mentioned in this sm discussion

 

Joe Calzaghe beat every top SMW at his time, he even beat the unbeatable Roy Jones JR of course he is the best ever, not only SMW but best ever fighter.

 

how do you figure when antonio tarver an glencoffe johnson already had knocked roy the **** out

 

idiotic thread, please name your ATG SMW list

 

Tarver and Johnson have lost too many fights to even be compared to Calzaghe, STFU and learn about boxing.

 

Toney, Jones jnr and a prime Nigel Benn (i'e the one that beat Mclellon)... other then that Calzaghe would probably beat the rest. Though he would look pretty **** doing it if you like neat, tidy boxers.

 

listen **** head it was in response to your lame referance to credit you gave joe for beating past prime roy who you refered to as unbeatable i made no referance to weather at or gcj was beter or had beter rec you idiot but at least the two afore mentioned challenged themselves in late stages of their carrers aginst current relevants you lame read your own quote before typing without thinking dickhead

 

Lol, Joe is undoubtedly the greatest super middle of all-time. It a relatively young division and he dominated it for a decade. The only ones who might have a claim are Steve Collins, Benn and Eubank.