Joe Calzaghe or Floyd Mayweather who is the higher ranked ATG???

LOL this was just embarassing. did slappy joe pay off refs on the reg? 90 percent of those stoppages were nonsense and should not have been stopped. calzaghe is horrendous to watch, makes me wince, worst style ever.

 

We may have to agree to disagree.

Castillo was a much more complete fighter than either Pavlik (one of my favorites) or Pascal (the inactive gasser). On that, most boxing fans will agree.

If a prime Hopkins struggled with either of those two guys he would have been ridiculed. The only thing that makes those victories special is Hopkins age. You take that out of the equation and you have a well-rounded fighter beating two one-dimensional guys.

 

before reading posts in this thread you gotta read location.....if it says england then ignore and move on to the next post

 

What the forum needs is a moderator whomactually acts as moderator. Like in the debates.

One party post their stuff and the other pary posts theirs.

It has to be broken into segments.
Example in this case ;

Let us talk first about :

1. Resume - who they fought, who they did not fight, how good are the fighters they fought, how would the fighters they fought compare to the fighters theother guy fought

2. Skills

3. Others that I can not think of.

There is never meaningful debates in ESB because everything under the sun is being discussed.

Let's start

1. 46 -0 vs. 42 - 0, Calzaghe 1 point (but Mayweather is still fighting)
2. Carrer-defining fights -----
3.
4.
5.




At the end of the day, this issue might be resolved, or not.

 

Who has Floyd beat that JC could not have beaten then make the same question the other way round! There you go JC should be ranked higher than Mayweather. Of course I am just joking but I would be interested to know which fighters JC beat that people think Mayweather would have beaten if put some fat on and fought at 168/175!

 

Calzaghe was dropped by 2 40 year old former middleweights

 

kill yourself

your wife is a 6/10 btw

 

FMJ and righfully so.

 

I have to go with Floyd on this one.

 

that is legendary! he could knock out opponents without even landing punches. tell me someone else that good! come on guy!:deal

 

don't forget that they were both champions with a combined record of 50+ wins and 1 loss. no point in discrediting Pascal when he had already proved he was the best light-heavy in the world when him and hopkins fought.

 

Is this question a joke or what ?

 

Its a joke that floyd is winning this poll!

 

Calzaghe. He did not beat up women like the chicken arse Void. Void is void. Void is still running from Pac! Void cheats..........

 

i pick Calzaghe