Joe Calzaghe retired 46-0 (32) in 2008. Get over it. Fans & haters; quit trolling!

The judges didnt all have Dawson winning either

 

. How can winning non-major titles like the ring and IBO and then losing them straight away be greater than winning and defending the unified/undisputed major MW titles for years on end.


idiot fool.

 

Remember how I said I tend to ignore your posts as they are always wrong and irrelevant and now you have caused me to look by butting in a conversation with another poster and once again, I have to point out to you, how you are wrong again . What an irrelevant waste of time you are :yep
Dawson won by Mdec :deal

 

that is true, but dawsons was a much more onesided win, albeit over slightly older Hopkins.


so dawson,better win than joe.

taylor, UD win.

point still stands, the same point you now still run from Failossunder the guise of telling me you are ignoring me by way of making a reply LOL. .

Treble flop failey - now THAT is why you "ignore" my posts - better to "ignore" it than admit you are unable to win against it.

 

117 -111 is pretty one sided

 

So is 116 - 111 years previously

 

treble flop failey why are you arguing back over a point you have already acknowledge you have lost?

Are you a petulant child?

 

What scored was that the Lacy fight ?

 

not in a split decision


anyways its pointless now, no one beat Bhop like Kovalev did

totally dominated the unified champ hopkins


something glass joe could never do

 

BTW glass joe doesnt have a glass chin

just a glass resume

 

I dont read a massive amount into Inkin and Mkertchian fighting when novices. Hopkins lost his debut and Mkertchian moved on quicker really when beating Chanet and beating Barr for a mandatory position, even if Inkin did overall do more with wins over Veit and winning the title. It was 2 novices fighting then

 

Although Jones may have been gifted and beaten some of the top SMWs in H2H, he just didnt do enough in the division for me to have him at the top. Wins over Toney, Malinga and a novice Lucas, dont really make it to the top. I think Collins may have one of the best SMW wins ever, but Calzaghe is a long way ahead IMO, with far more overall better wins.
Eubank has a great SMW resume and even though he lost to collins, taking into account the body of work at the weight, which is massive, to me goes ahead.
Ottke is an interesting one as I rate him highly at SMW, but feel he is a bit shy of Eubank, though I wouldnt argue too much if they were swapped, but Eubank has it for me. I cant see how Ottke would be above Calzaghe as he didnt beat anyone as good as Eubank or Kessler and I think Lacy would possibly have been Ottkes best win if he fought him and won. Still I did like what Ottke did on the tough european scene facing fighting like Markussen and L****n even former MW champ Krajnc

 

yes Mitchell was better than lacy I agree.


calzaghe easily defeated rubbish lacy, but needed a ref to save him from a crushing ko against Byron.

and still treble flop failey runs.

 

If not the best, he is certainly one of the best................