Joe Calzaghe retired 46-0 (32) in 2008. Get over it. Fans & haters; quit trolling!

What do you mean by greatest? By who he beat at 168? Or skill wise? I don't rate him as the greatest in either category at 168.

 

Greatest can crusher of 168

 

Good point.

 

I was a massive fan, but sadly Roy has some question marks that appeared around the Hall fight.

 

What spin?

 

Hey Bails at least they appreciate your work on here champ :good

 

I dont need to spin anything.
Roy was the #6 LHW and had wins over champs when the fight was signed as well as wins over other then current top 10 LHWs including the champ.
Ajamu I knew of and other than the first round, it looked like the Roy of old, like when he fought Frazier that not many knew of.
Hanshaw was undefeated and coming off a fight with another undefeated fighter.
Tito was put down twice and clearly beaten. Roy was able to take the shots off a WW and didnt need to be elusive.
Roy was getting himself back adjusted to LHW, so that he would be back to what we knew

 

I have backed you into corners but most of the self you paint yourself into them

 

Who do you feel has a better SMW resume...?
Wait for this answer to fall flat

 

Funny how people dont say so much about Holyfield beating LHWs in the new CW division

 

so now Roy was elite again after not having a signifigant win since Tarver 1 which was 5 yrs before his fight with Joe and getting brutally Ko'ed several times

 

Well it is the best :good

 

It took him time to get back adjusted to LHW.
Here read this

http://www.15rounds.com/roy-jones-jr-conference-call-transcript-110208/

http://sports.espn.go.com/sports/boxing/news/story?id=3684713

Amazing how all thses people claim Jones was shot yet cant explain the post below.
People say Roy was shot when Calzaghe beat him but show me where he was so different there to when he failed a test against R Hall and where the hand speed was so different. The difference was Jones was facing someone who could match him for speed and had a bit more ring generalship. Hall couldnt close the gaps like Calzaghe also Calzaghes foot movement was causing Jones problems

This content is protected

This content is protected

No doubt there will be some that say well if you cant tell the difference, but let them explain.
Nobody can tell me the difference in Jones, but you can see the difference between Calzaghe and Hall and that seemed to make a big difference