Lets say the Calzaghe that beat Kessler against the Hagler that lost to Ray Leonard at super middle weight. Who would win?
*Awaits that **** of a poster with joe in green/blue trunks in his avatar to go on about how 'sugar joe' would beat him etc*
You've gone and picked a faded Calzaghe vs a faded, inactive Hagler who had been banged up in his last two fights. Prime vs prime..... Hagler wins a clear decision. I wouldn't rule out a stoppage, but Calzaghe could take a decent shot and was a big super middle..... whilst Marvellous was only an average sized middle. Nobody beats Hagler at 160 H2H in a prime vs prime matchup. In fact there aren't many I'd pick to trouble him either.
Why did you say prime for prime then? Anyway i think Calzaghe's size would be a big factor here. Hagler wasn't a huge middleweight and Calzaghe would definitely be a lot bigger on fight night. Calzaghe decision.
Calzaghe comrotable points win Calzaghe has welterweight speed and HAgler couldn't convincingly beat a welterweight for the life of him. Absolute different classes of fighter, no need to ask this question.