Joe Calzhage Better ATG Than Mayweather ?

No. Reid, Hopkins, and Kessler does not cut it.

 

According to *****s...yes

46-0 > 43-0

 

Awwww, where's your mention of the free limo ride, free hotel stay and free buffet with every Floyd Mayweather ticket you purchase?

Surely that puts him higher on the list than soggy ol' Italian Dragon, slip-slappy Calzhage.

This content is protected

 

4 more non health risk fights and Floyd should be greater than Calzaghe.

 

It's now free buffet, free room, free limo ride, and 20% off.

 

That's about where I have Calzaghe, but you are criminally underrating Mayweather.

Top 5 ATG and arguably the GOAT at junior lightweight.
Entered RING P4P list in 98.
RING P4P #1 from 05-07.
98 and 07 Fighter of the Year.
Lineal championships at 130, 135, and 147.
Undefeated.

Even if you go through and nit-pick and spend hours and hours degrading each one of the very generically written achievements I have written, his resume adds up to a no doubt top 25 all timer.

 

Imo no,resume just not that good for me to put him above floyd

And I personally have Floyd a lot higher about top 30

 

doubt it, the name Calzaghe sounds familiar though, or am i thinking Calzone, ..silly belly

 

Floyd is one of the best ever and Calzaghe is one of the most overrated .

 

I like both but Floyd is higher and it's not even that close really.

 

Joe C is not even at top 100 consensus...Floyd is a top 40 consensus.

 

Mayweather is miles ahead of Calzaghe, who was an excellent fighter, but falls short in the resume department and the overall ability department. Mayweather at 130 is a much better package than Calzaghe in his prime at 168.

 

Floyd beat higher ranked opponents.