As someone who was a boxing fan during the 1970s, I didn't sense that the general public had that much sympathy for Joe Frazier. Of course, Joe Frazier couldn't come close to matching Muhammad Ali in terms of popularity despite having fighting style which was much more fan-friendly. It didn't help that Ali may have been the most compelling boxing figure of my lifetime. But I sensed that Frazier had more support among hardcore boxing fans than the casual ones at the time. Besides disliking Ali's fighting style, some hardcore fans were turned off by his actions and personality. When talking about Ali, some fight people and hardcore fans called him "Clay" long after he changed his name. - Chuck Johnston
Hardcore fighting fans back then were bunch of racist old men who wanted a humble champ. Frazier can have them. I'm sure he would feel the "love" and "respect" he deserves.
There always was and is today a portion of the public where race is a deciding factor. It's that way today and was that way in the 70's. However Ali rubbed many the wrong way with his bragging, showboating, degrading of opponents. Ali played the villain and when you play a villain expect a good portion of the public to root against you. This was what Ali wanted however. To be controversial, get people to want to see him lose so badly they would come and buy tickets to his fights. it's the "Gorgeous George" story that Ali told often. Many cheered for Frazier because quite simply he has the more likable personality while Alis brash loud manner took many aback.
I'm fully aware of why Ali was less popular than a lot of his fellow boxers, but to say it was solely down to racism is garbage, particularly if the opponents his haters were rooting for were themselves black. What rubbed people up the wrong way was the guy was radical, and highly outspoken.
Another thing I hate about Joe is how he asked for help from the public every couple of years. A charity case this guy was. Asking for help before he became a champion, asking for help in the 80's then in turn the 90's and 2000. The guy loved taking advantage of peoples sympathy. As a man, I can not respect that.
A historian should not have a favourite fighter. In practice we all fail to meet this ideal, but it is what we should aspire to.
Very strong statements. I know of no one who shares that viewpoint and I live 90 min from Philadelphia.