Joe Frazier vs Rocky Marciano : who wins?

Two inside pressure fighters, one of them is bigger, more accurate, faster and stronger. He just had the misfortune to come along in a much stronger era.

Frazier backs Marciano up(!) and that's why he eventually stops him. Heart and determination won't pull him through because Frazier matches him in that regard.

I don't think the power difference being in Marciano's favour is a foregone conclusion, either.

 

The slower starting Frazier gets dropped in the first couple of rounds,but recovers and in a seesawing bout,cuts Rocky up so badly that the referee stops the fight in Smokin' Joe's favour around the eighth or ninth.


A non stop all action fight.

 

i said it 100 times and i will repeat it 100 times, joe frazier was better than marciano and he was naturally 20 pounds bigger(not fat, frame,) he was the thicker man, he was faster, more skilled, he had better defence(yes absolutely better defence) he had better body work, he was more accurate puncher, he was better body puncher, he had as much heart and stamina and frazier simply destroyed every guy under 200 pounds, marciano fought wars with walcott or charles,even an ancient moore dropped him, frazier demolished bob foster like nothing, saying that rocky had a better chin than frazier is simply laughable, simply frazier faced a harder puncher, stronger men and better men than rocky did

 

sir, this comment is the pure truth

 

It would be a war but Frazier would prevail due to his speed. He was faster on the attack and he whipped his shots in faster than Rocky did. plus Joe was not a one handed fighter like many claim. When he chose to, he had a damaging right which he could put to good use like he did against Quarry and he had an underrated jab which he actually used effectively against Ali in thier first fight. Also Joe's bobbing and weaving would make it hard for Rocky to score with his own right hand and I don't see him putting Joe down for the count. Even George Foreman couldn't do that and that was against a past prime Frazier. What I do see happening is Frazier, after going thru hell in the first few rounds begins to gradually and consistently beat Rocky to the punch with his speed. Sometime late in the fight...maybe around the 13th or 14th round Joe really begins to land the hook with increasingly devestating effect probably forcing the referee to stop the fight either due to cuts or by calling a tko on a battered but valiant Marciano. If you couldn't stop Frazier you were in for a long night and I just don't see Rocky stopping Joe. Hurting him? Yes. Stopping him? No.

 

Frazier said only 2 men that he would admit could beat him, Louis and Marciano who he was a big fan of and I agree with Joe Frazier but a prime Frazier gives any man hell, not he version that fought Foreman or Ali in 2&3 but the FOTC Frazier goes out with a big bang or takes you

 

The Rock just wasnt busy enough top keep Joe off him, Just the wrong style for Frazier to expose...Joe smothers him pumpin in lookin for those bigshots ( That Left Hook) I do see him making Rocky miss and Joe makin him pay for it evertime...I say Joe KO around the &th or 8th

 

No.

e was better because e was twenty pounds eavier. It is debatable, but I tend to aree.

But pound-for-pound - Marciano was as scary or scarier. Between 175 and 190lbs tere is only a andful of boxers on is level.

 

Gotta go with Joe here.

It would be interesting how well he can take Rocky's right hand (doubly so for Marciano on how he fares against Frazier's left hook).

 

Going with Marciano here.

For one, Joe was not, as someone stated, stronger than Marciano, not a by a long shot. And Joe certainly did not hit harder.

One of the greatest all-time wars would ensue but my money is on Marciano. Stronger, harder hitter, at least as resilient.

I would sell most everything dear to be front and center on this one.

 

Then no one is

The only thing I'm going to say is the idea that this is a stylistic advantage for Frazier is an error in judgement. If Frazier wins it's because he's of a slightly higher quality. Not because of styles.

 

Frazier would give Marciano the Ali treatment (FOTC).

 

I sgree.:good