Joe frazier was better than marciano in everything

Common sense should tell youy that they both had different strengths and weakneses.

 

Sometimes the whole is MORE than the sum of its parts.
Im sure janny will concur...

 

I'd think you'd be hard pressed to justify either being more conditioned than the other.

 

Well, whatever gets people posting.

 

As far as chin is concerned:
Marciano got dropped by Walcott and Moore.
Frazier was dropped by Ringo and Foreman.

There isn't any question in my mind that both Foreman and Bonavena hit harder on the one-punch than Walcott or Moore.

Anyone can be dropped, and all hitters concerned hit hard enough to hurt just about anyone.

That doesn't mean Frazier's chin was better, necessarily because he got up and stayed up. Frazier went down at least twice on both occasions. I think Frazier fought harder punchers in general than Marciano, but I think Marciano could have done well enough in Frazier's shoes.

So what does this all mean?

It means both men had good, but not great, chins. Both guys were sturdy, but either could be dropped.

 

I think anyone suggesting such a thing is not only uninformed but a terrible, terrible person. :bart

 

I agree. Such a fellow should be held in the stocks and pelted with old tomatoes...
He should also be excommunicated to MMA.

 

Some Rocky fanboys even try to say Rocky had a better right hand than Joe, LUDICROUS

 

preacher sonny liston.wrong thread hahaha

 

But Frazier wasnt only droped by Ringo and Foreman. I think he was also droped by Scrap Iron Johnson.

If that is the case then the edge should go to Rocky.