Americans like to say .."bl bla bl .... but he wouldn't win". Well, although Roy is one of my favorite fighters I would not rule out that Joe culd win. Not at all. Imo. although Joe is not American and it hurts deep down for an American aknowledging that Roy could loose - I think it is being too biased saying that an undefeated fighter with perhaps the best ever SMW record could not have won. Understandably many -wish- that he could not have won. I think Joe would have had a good chance in Cardiff, Wales. In the US I would think Roy would be favorite, but Joe would still have a fair chance. Regsarding Hopkins.. Hopkins was never at no point in his carreer anywhere near as active as Calzaghe.