Joe vs the best

vs. Roy Jones @ 168: Jones UD
vs. James Toney @ 168: Calzaghe UD
vs. Mike McCallum @ 168: Calzaghe UD
vs. Michael Nunn @ 168: Calzaghe UD
vs. Chris Eubank @ 168: Calzaghe UD
vs. Nigel Benn @ 168: Calzaghe UD
vs. Steve Collins @ 168: Calzaghe UD
vs. Herol Graham @ 168: Calzaghe TKO
vs. Gerald McClellan @ 168: Calzaghe UD

 

vs. Jones: Jones UD
vs. Toney: Calzaghe UD
vs. McCallum: Calzaghe UD
vs. Nunn: Calzaghe UD
vs. Eubank: Calzaghe UD
vs. Benn: Calzaghe TKO
vs. Collins: Calzaghe UD
vs. Graham: Calzaghe UD
vs. McClellan: Calzaghe UD

 

im with hypnotoad, i think the first four all beat joe and joe beats all the rest

go hypnotoad

 

vs. Jones: Jones UD
vs. Toney: Toney SD
vs. McCallum: Calzaghe UD
vs. Nunn: Calzaghe UD
vs. Eubank: Calzaghe UD
vs. Benn: Calzaghe UD
vs. Collins: Calzaghe UD
vs. Graham: Graham UD
vs. McClellan: McClellan KO

 

1.jones by ko
2.toney by ko
3.joe cby ud
4.nunn by sd
5.joe c
6. joe c
7.joec
but against glen johnson now he'll get koed

 

1. Roy Jones - Jones
2. James Toney - Toney
3. Mike McCallum - Joe
4. Michael Nunn - Joe
5. Chris Eubank - Joe
6.Nigel Benn - Benn
7. Steve Collins - Joe
8. Herol Graham - Joe
9. G-Man - G-Man

 

1. Roy Jones vs JC- UD Jones

2. James Toney vs JC - UD JC

3. Mike McCallum vs JC - draw

4. Michael Nunn vs JC - Late TKO JC

5. Chris Eubank vs JC - SD JC

6.Nigel Benn vs JC - mid rounds TKO JC

7. Steve Collins vs JC - UD JC

8. Herol Graham vs JC - SD JC

9. G-man vs JC - UD JC

 

All prime for prime.

1. Roy Jones/ RoyJones KO/TKO

2. James Toney/ Toney KO/TKO

3. Bernard Hopkins/ Hopkins KO/TKO poss UD

4. Michael Nunn/ Nunn TKO/KO

5. Chris Eubank/ Eubank SD/UD

6. Nigel Benn/ Benn KO/TKO or Calzaghe UD

7. Steve Collins /Calzaghe SD

8. Herol Graham /Calzaghe UD

 

I think he'd beat Collins and Graham

 

Roy Jones is the only one I would perhaps make favorite over Joe Calzaghe.

For this reason we should perhaps consider not acknowledging prime Roy Jone Jr ever existed.

 

I also think Joe takes them all except Roy.

 

James toney?!

 

James Toney is very skilled.

James Toney used to be very athletic and had an excellent workrate and stamina. Which many people forget.

But he was very hit and miss vs the elite opponents and I consider Joe Calzageh the upperend of elite. If Toney had distinguisded himself truly from the Griffins, MaCallums etc the argument could be made, but he didn't. And without any apparent stylistic advantage I see no reason to pick him.

Hopkins has the better case, simply because of his style. Though I still pick the younger version of Calzaghe of the best Hopkins, though I'll acknowledge he would cause massive problems for a few rounds.