joecal's vs pedjr's 46-0.

Wow 2 fluffy records from boxing's greatest cherry pickers :think

This is a tough one but Floyd has the better resume ..

The Hopkins win does elevate Joe's a bit but Floyd did much better south of 140

There also needs to be a 3rd option

 

Slappy beat the GOAT and the Alien.....prime Kessler, prime Bika, prime and undefeated Lacy(who was supposed to mow down a Klitschko one day), prime Sheika, prime Reid, prime Eubank, prime Woodall.

That's 4 top 20 ATGs and at least one more HOFer.

He never ducked a mandatory. Not once. He never dropped his title and retired to duck a fight.

I hated Calslappy far more than I dislike Roid Mayflower......but Joe's is better. 8yrs after he beat Roidnard and the GOAT, the GOAT is still winning minor titles at CW and beating or holding his own with top prospects and titlists, and Roidnard is unifying LHW world titles in far easier fashion than Roid Jr did last night.:yep

 

Floyd lost to jlc and chino. 46-0> 44-2

 

Anybody voting for Joe is absolutely deluded haha.

 

no coincidence progamer made this thread
bailey would have made one too if Floyd lost...and tried to sound sincere doing it

 

Joe's win over Hopkins is better than ANY of Void's wins. That's a fact.

 

Floyd has the better resume lets not over look what he did south of 140

 

His best win down that way is Corrales. Please...

 

And Castillo look where he was ranked at the time he beat him come on now ..I'm one of his biggest critics but Floyd has a much deeper resume than Joe ..


And prior to Hopkins who was Joe's best win ? A faded Eubanks ?

 

:goodYup:thumbsup

Nice username too btw.....

Loved me some Danny Williams before he got scrambled.

 

if you want to live and die by the flag, be my guest....

 

Well, who is it? Gatti? N'Dou?

 

South of 140

 

compared to a prime Kessler or 40 year old hopkins who got dethroned by jermain taylor?
at the end of the day, brits want joe to compare to Hopkins and jones - and it's just not going to be remembered that way