They are about the same height, Broner has a 5 inch reach advantage, is faster, and in my opinion naturally bigger. Experience edge, chin, and heart goes to Chavez Sr. right now though. Would be a great fight to see at 135, would be interesting to see how he would handle the style and how Broner would adjust.
Chavez would be too seasoned for Broner at that stage of his career .. He would have his moment but lack of deep water experience would become apparent after round 5 . and thats only because chavez is a slow starter.
Taylor took the most damage. Rosario and Camacho are pretty close I'd guess, maybe Rosario got the worst of it because he stood and banged it out with JCC, but Camacho ate a TON of shots. Probably the worst sustained beating of his career.
I don't think you can even give the defensive edge to Broner. JCC was VERY elusive when he wanted to be. He just usually didn't give a **** after he knew he could take your best and he'd accept a shot to give one.
Camacho took a bad beating no doubt but your solely looking at this from a physical perspective. Taylor and Rosario both stood toe to toe with Chavez whereas Camacho was holding and running a lot. He still took punches but he was trying to keep distance reducing the damage.
:deal,Guy was pissing blood & was never the same again.He'd have broner doing the judah chicken dance or put him to sleep like his idol over there.
Dude went up and won the WW title after the loss and defened it 5 times, cut the BS of he was never the same. I'd say the Norris destruction was more a sign of the end than anything else.