Who wins this hypothetical fight? I think this is a genuine 50-50 fight as both are similar in ability and stature.
Fair enough lol I just thought they're like clones of each other and come to think of it they're also both of Arab descent fighting out of Germany.
Kabayel is Turkish or Kurdish or something, not Arabic I think. As to your question Kabayel beats any version of Charr. Kabayel was once upon a time a fairly decent fighter. No idea what he's like now since he seems to have fallen off the radar.