**** Kirks Championships 2013 ****

Unless Sturm is involved better said.

 

Sturm fought in Japan? :huh

 

I was meaning as in home advantage, not necessarily Japan only.

 

Yes but the original statement referred specifically to Japan and not home-cooking in general. If you follow the lines of quotes, it goes:

"There's usually very good judging in Japan. ...Unless a Kameda is involved." (as I put it)

or

"There's usually very good judging in Japan. ...Unless Sturm is involved." (as you put it)

:yep

 

Oh and Sturm was on the wrong end of more decisions - even in Germany - than he benefited from. :good

:deal

 

:good

 

BeastsideBoxing vs Robney
Round 1 - Alexander Alekseev vs. Garrett Wilson: Alekseev UD 10-9 Robney
Beastsideboxing : Alekseev TKO 4
Robney : Alekseev Wide UD
Round 2 - Lamont Peterson vs. Kendall Holt: Peterson TKO8 10-10 DRAW!
Beastsideboxing : Peterson Wide UD
Robney : Peterson Close UD
Round 3 - Art Hovhannisyan vs. Alejandro Perez: Perez UD 10-10 DRAW!
Beastsideboxing : Hovhannisyan Close UD
Robney : Hovhannisyan Wide UD
Round 4 - Christopher Martin vs. Jose Angel Beranza: Martin Close UD 10-9 Beastside...
Beastsideboxing : Martin Close UD
Robney : Martin Wide UD
Round 5 - David Price vs. Tony Thompson: Thompson TKO2 10-10 Draw
Beastsideboxing : David Price TKO6
Robney : Price T/KO7
Round 6 - Cornelius Bundrage vs. Ishe Smith : Smith SD 10-8 Beastsideboxing
Beastsideboxing : Smith Close UD
Robney : Bundrage Close UD
Round 7 - David Sanchez - Marlon Tapales : David Sanchez MD 10-10 DRAW!
Beastsideboxing : Sanchez TKO5
Robney : Sanchez T/KO7
Round 8 - Juan Carlos Reveco vs. Masayuki Kuroda : Reveco UD 10-10 DRAW!
Beastsideboxing : Reveco Wide UD
Robney : Reveco Wide UD
Round 9 -
Beastsideboxing :
Robney :
Round 10 -
Beastsideboxing :
Robney :
Round 11 -
Beastsideboxing :
Robney :
Round 12 -
Beastsideboxing :
Robney :
--------------------------------------------------------

 

Bump.

So what do you guys think on UD's based on rounds ratio with variations?
By variations I mean points deduction, and draw rounds.

 

I still have a question about that...

If you don't count draw rounds and point deductions, and the fight ends up to be decided by those (take the Khan vs Peterson fight for example), then how is that bout scored? :blood

 

What was the rounds ration on that one ?

 

J1: 9-3 Khan
J2: 6-6
J3: 6-6
(peterson down once. Khan got 2 points deducted for pushing)

So without the deductions Khan would have won by close UD, now Peterson won by SD. :yep

 

The scorecard at Peterson-Khan was 113-115 without the 3 faults deductions of Khan.

So that's a 7-5 for Khan, but Amir get's 3 points deduction so that makes 4-5 for Peterson. I guess if You have picked Peterson by 7-5 would've been the closest. If you had an epifeny and would've think that one round would be a Draw and say 7-6 for Peterson you would have been ever closer and beat the 7-5 prediction.

113-112 where the cards after deductions the guy who picks 7-5 (as in smalles diference in rounds) for Peterson wins 10-9 the WBK round.

 

By Kirk's rules 9-3 is ruled out.

 

There were 2 point deductions for Khan, and the official scores were
Kha - Pet
115 - 110
112 - 113
112 - 113

without deductions it would be
Kha - Pet
117 - 110
114 - 113
114 - 113

 

Peterson was down and 7-5 was transformed into 6-5, plus the 2 points deduction it transformed int 4-5. Same thing 7-6 is the closest followed by normal 7-5 for Peterson