Thanks for posting the donaire fight i hadnt seen it yet. I think hes done on the top level but he can still make for some good matchups n fights. I look forward to his next big fight.
Kirk we should change the name of Peoples Champion.... to something else. Idk... Kirks league: "Title Holder" "Interim Champion" ohh ohh... I got a good one "Reigning Champion" huuh?!
That was a close fight could have gone eather way, this was no robbery so you can't argue with the judges on this fight. It is what it is. :deal
This thread is about testing your Boxing knowledge and I picked Vanes for the win and I was right and at the very least it was a draw, there should be some caveat when there is a highly disputed result when someone is robbed or the decision is debatable, that the people who chose the actual winner gets credit as well it shouldn't count as a loss. The ones who picked Charlo were wrong but should get credit for it since he got the decision. Yet the ones who picked Vanes were technically right we should get a win as well. It wouldn't put me ahead.....of the ones who picked Charlo that would be fair wouldn't it.:good Also it was a close fight and doesn't Kirk throw out draws, well maybe when there's a disputed decision everyone should get credit. Thread title states "Know Boxing? Come Prove It" well I did. This is the second time I've done this......the first time was in January I laid out on the RBR how Tony Luis would beat Karl Dargan and how I thought he'd win.....but I didn't pick him because I thought they'd rob him and Luis won in the manner I predicted and they actually gave him credit for it yet I didn't get the win because of fear of a judges screwjob. A new rule should be laid out when someone proves their knowledge we shouldn't get screwed.
Kirk goes by what the judges pick the winner and that is how its been he' s not going to change things after all these years. We have all been robbed in fights but it is what it is. Do you think people that placed a bet in Las Vages or on a betting site that bet on Vanes got their money back ''ah nope they did not".
Well this isn't Vegas and draws are thrown out so why can't with disputed decisions everyone get credit.:conf Then everyone would be happy. It should be about "Proving your Knowledge":deal
Because every close fight their would be an argument thats why it would not work, thats why you go by the judges desion, and again that was such a close fight I my self thougt Charlos won by a point. Next time pick Charlos:good
Simple solution to that, if someone says its a disputed decision and it truly is let kirk and Pinoy be the judges, if they think it is, everyone gets get credit for a win, and if they don't think it is... the result stands. At least give it some consideration.:thumbsup
Kirks Championships has been fine all these years again this was not a robbery it was a close fight and the judes made the call we are not the judges.:deal I know it hard losing but the year is not over :good I can see it now one day were going to be in line in front of the pearly gate waiting to get in and the line will all of a sudden be at a stand still and come to find out it's CST80 holding up the line trying to change the 10 Commandments.:yep