Alis jab was lightening-quick, no doubt. But don't always go by the Liston fight. Sonny was slow and ponderous at times. He only moved forward, never side-to-side. His footwork was below-average 'at best'. He didn't bend to avoid punches, he leaned down and forward. His arms 'muscle-mass' were big and heavy, making it difficult to keep them up in front of his face. Thats just a start.
On the Renaldo 'Mr.' Snipes vs. Holmes. Renaldo Snipes lived right near me in Westchester County. I saw him fight many times in White Plains, New York. The guy was awkward, but did throw a wild right hand. At 25-years old, 6' 2" and 215 lbs. he was a 'live' opponent for Larry Holmes. Unbeaten in 22 fights, and with (11 KO's) he was not an easy guy to fight. None of Ali's first (8) defenses had that kind of 'live' opponent. Young, strong, unconventional, and unbeaten.
Larry had a shortcoming he never overcame and its not well known because most heavies aren't movers like Ali was. When facing a moving target Larry would step after them without throwing punches until they stopped, then he would set himself and deliver. Even in the awful bout he had with Ali whenever Muhammad would move slowly around the ring Larry would just follow without throwing a single punch until Ali would stop. Ali in his prime would have used his movement and Larrys weakness in that area to take most of the rounds and the decision.
Ali was good, but Holmes would kick his ass! I think Holmes would jab would make ali's useless, but Larry would have top beware of Ali's counter right. Holmes would batter him.
It looks like the Gentro-Computer was using some combination of fights to determine the winner. Only Ali's fights from 63' thru 67', were calculated. He lost points for not fighting; 1966,, Eddie Machen,,47-6-3 (29 KO's),, (33) 6' 0" 192 lbs. 1966,, Amos Lincoln,, 38-5-0 (24 KO's),, (30) 6' 2" 205 lbs. 1966,, Thad Spencer,, 30-5-0 (13 KO's),, (23) 5' 11" 197 lbs. 1967,, Leotis Martin,, 24-1-0 (14 KO's),, (28 6' 1" 198 lbs. 1966,, Doug Jones ,, 24-4-1 (14 KO's),, (29) 6' 0" 195 lbs. 1967,, Eduardo Corletti 23-2-5 (13 KO's),,(26) 6' 1" 198 lbs.
I think what the computer was stating, is that; Any combination of Machen, Lincoln, Spencer, Martin, Jones or Corletti were better than George Chuvalo, Brian London, Henry Cooper or Cleveland Williams. The computer also has Renaldo Snipes as a more dangerous fighter than any of Ali's first 8 defenses. Not better fighter, just more dangerous (based on youth, strength, size, unbeaten record, and right hand power).
finally some people on here agree with me and not on the whole ali hype train. Ali was good but also the most overrated boxer of all time holmes would beat him. Also a 71 frazier would beat any version of Ali. Prime Tyson puts Ali in hospital.
No fighter is unbeatable. Ali was more dominant in the 60s, yes, because he fought inferior opposition. No Frazier, no Foreman, no Norton, no Young but a Mildenberger, Cooper, London, Jones.
alexvoce, Very good point. 1971 version of Joe Frazier beats the best Cassius Clay 1963-1967 era. Have to laugh, watching Karl Mildenberger back-up Clay pretty much the whole fight in 1966. Also, hurting him with a body punch. How hard a puncher was Mildenberger. In his previous 27 fights, (4) big knock-outs. I wouldn't say Holmes wins easy, that would be a crazy statement. But Holmes wins a razor-thin decision.