***LATEST Ring Magazine Pound-for-Pound rankings***

That seems fair I'm glad they have acknowledged that Roy was shot to **** - rather then go with the knee jerk reaction. It wouldn't have been right for someone to go p4p no 1 off beating a totally shot fighter otherwise everyone might as well do it.

 

The pac/Marq fights were very close.

 

These are the panel of guys that collectively compile the p4p top ten list

Mark Abrams 15rounds.com
Carlos Arias Orange County Register
Eric Armit British Boxing Yearbook
Nick Charles Showtime
Brian Doogan London Sunday Times
Coyote Duran doghouseboxing.com
Margaret Goodman, M.D. secondsout.com
Steve Farhood Showtime
Doug Fischer maxboxing.com
Lee Groves CompuBox
Jack Hirsch Boxing News
Michael Hirsley Chicago Tribune
Keith Idec Herald News of New Jersey
Carlos Irusta El Grafico
Ted Lerner The Ring
Marc Lichtenfeld Through The Ropes
Jessi Losado Telemundo
Scott Mallon thesweetscience.com
Rich Marotta FSN-TV, KFI/KLAC Radio
David Mayo Grand Rapids Press

This content is protected

McGuigan ITV
Marty Mulcahey maxboxing.com
Bernard Osuna Telefutura
Vittorio Parisi nonsoloboxe.it
Cliff Rold ***********.com
Rick Scharmberg fightnews.com
Don Steinberg The Philadelphia Inquirer
Joe Tessitore ESPN
Paul Upham Fist/FSN-TV
Calvin Watkins Dallas Morning News
John Whistler San Antonio Express News
Phil Woolever Boxing Digest
Kurt Wolfheimer fightnews.com

 

He holds a win over the Number 6 guy. You don't think PW should be top ten?

 

Yeah, WTF?

 

Hatton should be ten, hes done a little more than PW, hes only lost to the P4P King.

 

Why the award "WBC emeritus" champion for still active fighters?

 

This panel give their opinions in order to assist the 'editorial board' upon their judgements. This panel does not decide the Ring ratings though, it is the 'editorial board' who do so

 

Let's get this straight... Calzaghe fell a position, didn't he??

 

Keepkin it real. Hard to believe some people rate Calzaghe higher than JMM.

 

No he's stopped at no 3.

 

Oh Yea, cheers. It's still an pretty extensive list of names though on the panel - I was originally surprised to see

This content is protected

McGuigan there.

 

You can make a case for Hatton to be top ten, but if you agree that Margo is #6, it's hard to make a case that the man who beat him would be five steps below him in the pound for pound rankings.

 

good list

 

why should he... just look at his resume and u can understand why he is still at the same spot