Legacy: Winky Wright or Juan Manuel Marquez

JMM



No question. Why is this even up for discussion...?

 

Winky was a phenominal fighter

But Juan's the man

:smoke

 

Marquez but don't forget Winky Wright was robbed against Jermaine Taylor for the MW Championship and Vargas. Some say he was robbed against Simon, I didn't see that though

 

JMM ATG
Winky HoF

love both respect both

 

Marquez.

And it isnt even close.

 

Marquez has the greater Legacy.
IMO Winky Wright is the better H2H fighter when it comes to facing past greats.

I want to see both in the HOF.

 

Winky Wright has the better wins on his resume.

 

JMM by far.

 

The smaller Shane Mosley
The smaller Tito Trinidad
The smaller Ike Quartey
A draw with Jermain Taylor

What did I miss? :huh

 

:rofl

 

Who is the numbnuts who voted for Winky lol

 

Mosley and Trinidad are better wins than anyone on Marquez resume, sorry to break it to you.

Shot versions of Barrera and Casamoyor? Or Katsidis and Diaz?!

 

this poll isnt fair to winky, you put him up against too tough of competition. I almost gave him a pity vote but its not even close enough for that, and I was a big fan of wright.

 

Come on pal :huh

Mosley the former LW.
Trinidad; the former WW who'd just come off a huge lay off and beat the amazing Ricardo Mayorga in a fight where they traded knockdowns?

Marquez has :

Gainer
Salido
Barrera
Juarez
Casamayor
Diaz (Bigger guy, and one of the three top LW's the first time they fought)
Katsidis (Bigger guy)

And three incredibly close fights with the P4P fighter of this decade.