Oh man, talk about a punch stat breaker. I always thought Dorin was underrated. The way he beat the living **** out of Augustus always stuck with me. There were multiple 10-8 rounds in that one even with no knockdowns.
Great fight. Maybe even better than Dorin vs Katsidis. Don't know who would have won but Dorin was IMO a little bit better technically. Not sure but great fight.
I thought Holiday was a little taller, better technically and boxed more than Dorin. Holiday by decision probably.
The only thing I know about Holiday is that he did better against Sugar Shane than anyone else for a long long time. But based on the Spadifora fight and the fact that Holiday is much of a puncher I would vote Dorin.