Let's see your pound for pound lists gents

Your list good. But nobody gets close to Hatton at 140. What more do you need to prove a P4P top 10?

 

You guys are right, i forgot Hatton. He would be my number 8 right after B-Hop squeezing out Margo.

 

Yep, that's a bit closer to what I might do.

 

1.) Manny Pacquiao
2.) Juan Manuel Marquez
3.) Joe Calzaghe
4.) Israel Vazquez
5.) Kelly Pavlik
6.) Rafael Marquez
7.) Bernard Hopkins
8.) Cristian Mijares
9.) Ivan Calderon
10.) Antonio Margarito

 

To add to what you guys are saying I'd probably have Margarito out at 10 and put Hatton in there. Maybe even lower for Hatton.

 

1. Calzaghe
2. Pacquiao
3. Marquez
4. Haye
5. Vasquez
6. Hatton
7. Hopkins
8. Magarito
9. Calderon
10. Pavlick

 

Yeah Hatton,Calderon and Cotto all very close.
I tell you what after what i just saw against Margarito is it just me or does a Hatton vs Cotto fight look like possible a great one for the future.
Maybe at 147 but in England.
I think with a solid win against Malignaggi Hatton will go back in my top ten.

 

I have a problem with rating Margo high on a pound 4 pound list when Margo wins due mainly to his size advantage. Its clear he had the size advantage over Cotto, was like a WW vs a MW.

 

1. Manny Pacquaio
2. Joe Calzaghe
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Isreal Vasquez
5. Rafeal Marquez
6. Kelly Pavlik
7. Cristen Mijares
8. Bernard Hopkins.
9. Antonio Margarito
10. David Haye

 

Margo wins due mainly to his size advantage.

:rofl

Margo spent the whole fight on Cotto's toes, size had nothing to do with it.

 

Course it does. Ability absorb more damage and heavier hands, greater strength, generally. Margarito is a MW sized fighter, id like to see him go toe to toe with a MW....Pavlik anyone?

 

Me personally i dont think it was size deffirence in this fight.

Sorry but NO.

It was however his great great chin and massive heart that drove straight through all the punch's he took early on. I dont think it was his size at all.

 

They were both 147lbs and Cotto is a prety big Welterweight. This was not Hatton vs Wlad.