list your all time top 10 p4p ratings.

Loving the Dixon kool aide at the moment arent ya Pea?

 

A bit more than the McAuliffe brand anyway. That list was an experiment anyway, just looking for a few opinions.

 

Cant say I know much about him...other then Id have him behind Langford and McLarnin in my Canadian rankings.

 

Mysterious Billy Smith should def be on that list.

 

1 Ray Robinson
2 Harry Greb
3 Sam Langford
4 Ezzard Charles
5 Roberto Duran
6 Henry Armstrong
7 Willie Pep
8 Muhammed Ali
9 Benny Leonard
10 Ray Leonard

 

Frankenwank; WORST
LIST
EVER
:rofl

 

Off the top of my head

1. Ray Robinson
2. Roberto Duran
3. Henry Armstrong
4. Harry Greb
5. Ezzard Charles
6. Ali
7. Langford


That was without thinking, the last couple need some more thought. Thinking Ross, Loughran, Ted Lewis, Hagler, Berg, Arguello. All close.

Probably some glaring omissions and if I really think the order might change but these 7 (plus Ross) are pretty much the best 8 fighters I've ever heard of (resume+skill=all-time standing)

 

By the way, what have I missed about Young Peter Jackson? Never heard of him.

 

This content is protected

Wins over Philadelphia Jack O'Brien, Mysterious Billy Smith, Barbados Joe Walcott, Sam Langford, all by TKO's.

Let's not forget however that all these men generally got the better of him despite Jackson also scoring wins over them.

Impressive fighter but top 3 pound for pound? That's a stretch.

 

:good Couldn't find anyhting comprehensive online. As always you are The Man:good:good:deal

 

whitaker above Ali and Duran? Another truly shite list

 

According to Boxrec, anyway? His record there is very incomplete according to most accounts, marred by robberies and dives galore as well. The best opponents he faced were probably Jim Driscoll, Abe Attell, Terry McGovern, and Young Griffo.

 

This thread is like eight tabs of acid to the face.

 

Duran above Robinson !!?!?
What are you nuts ?