List your Top 5 Middleweights

1. Martinez
2. Sturm
3. Chavez Jr
4. Geale
5. Pirog

 

Burley's too high

 

1. Martinez
2. Sturm
3. Chavez Jr
4. Golovkin
5. Pirog

I don't really like Sturm, but at this point has proven more than Jr, Golovkin, and Pirog.

 

H2H I think:
Martinez
Lee (Although I think he beats Martinez)
Pirog
Golovkin
Chavez or N'dam

 

Post the resume of a MW other than Sergio Martinez who has a better resume than Daniel Geale, please. You won't be able to (other than Sturm, who has by most accounts lost 2 of his last 3).

Daniel Geale (27-1, KO 15)
W UD12 Daniel Dawson (29-0)
L SD12 Anthony Mundine (35-3)
W TKO12 Roman Karmazin (40-3-2)
W SD12 Sebastian Sylvester (34-3-1)
W UD12 Eromosele Albert (24-4-1)
W UD12 Osumanu Adama (20-2)

 

Martinez

The rest is really tough to say because they are all close.....
Pirog and Golovkin are the best IMO though.....the most talented.

 

1. SRR
2. Lamotta

the rest

 

1. Sergio Martinez
2. Dmitry Pirog
3. andy lee
4. sturm
5. nkam

 

1. Martinez
2. Geale
3. Pirog
4. Golovkin
5. Sturm

 

The only reason this resume is better is because all others' are crap not because it is actually a decent resume. Also, I think people rank Geale lower than the other top MWs despite the better resume is probably because they feel he is less talented than them.

 

sergio
sturm
lee
chavez jr
golovkin

 

Gennady and Sergio are the only ones who matter. They are the only guys who have any balls. Chavez is a cherry picker. Sturm is a German ***. Point is,Sergio is the man right now but he is old and Gennady is gonna rule that division with an Iron Fist very soon. All Gennady needs is an opportunity from one of these cowards. He'll put one right on Sturm's chin.
Zbik is a good guy and a good fighter but he's all done. Macklin is nothing but a tough guy. Pirog is talented but he's not the man with that extra something.
It's Gennady. He is the future.

 

1. Sergio Martinez
2. Felix Sturm
3. Daniel Geale
4. Gennady Golovkin
5. Matthew Macklin (arguably beat #2 and gave #1 trouble in their bout)


Pirog's last bout showed me he's there to be hit against someone who has a good chin (Ishida landed 48% of his power shots on him.) Against one of the better guys on this list that's not gonna fly, so he fell off a bit for me. Really interested in GGG though, he's got the future of the MW division in his hands.