If something looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it may just be a duck. btw, always enjoyed reading Jim Murray, and from all accounts he was a great gentleman and all around fine fellow, and may he RIP.
both liston and bonavena were coming in to him as Ali's punch connected. i think liston was caught cold and hit by a perfectly timed punch he didn't see (his foot is off the ground) - he probably stayed down but he was up and still fighting when it was stopped by Walcott - bloody Nat Fleisher. I think it was only the 2nd or 3rd punch Ali threw in the fight.
Personally, I really don't know about this one. If Liston's cornerman said he asked for the smelling salt that do bear weight for me, on the other hand it really did look fake when he fell flat on his back and spread his arms out... I just don't know about this one. Liston acted so bizarr in both fights. Mysterious guy, no doubt. What I do know though is that I count Jim Cannon's opinions about as highly as I do Red Smith's when it comes to Ali. The both hated him and took every opportunity to critize him, so what they say concerning Ali doesn't carry much weight with me.
To be honest I see it as a punch that could cause a flash KD (because of the surprise factor and Liston being off balance), but of course I have a hard time seeing it KO a guy like Liston. It's a sneaky punch, but definitely not a power punch. The thing is, there's a lot we don't know about Liston's condition at the time, physical and mental. As we all know he died of a heroine overdose, and some believe he took the stuff back then already. For me there's just a lot of questions unaswered in both fights, I can't come to one really certain conclusion. As I said, the man was a mystery.
One more controversy to ask about though Nat, the second Ali-Liston fight. Did Liston take a dive? Nat Fleischer: I was sitting next to the timekeeper Frank McDonough. It is true, that after the knockdown, Walcott, who was acting as referee, allowed them to resume fighting. But the count had reached 10, Liston was actually lying on the canvas 20 seconds. I had caught Walcott's attention and McDonough informed him that the count had reached 10 and so Walcott stopped the fight. Liston never got the count. It was unpopular and cries of fake came from the crowd. But I believe the punch to be real. I saw it from the best seat in the house. After seeing the punch as Clay tossed it with a twist, then watching it several times on TV, there can be no doubt that is was This content is protected that dropped Liston. It was the same kind of punch and that is why, despite not looking impressive at a glance, it was quite damaging. Coxs Corner: I basically agree. If you watch the fight on slow-motion replay you can see Listons head snap from the blow. He never saw it and those are the ones that usually do the trick. It was enough to knock him down but I don't think it was enough to knock him out. I thought the real controversy was the way the fight was stopped. Liston never received a count and Ali never went to a neutral corner. Liston later said he couldnt get up because Ali was standing over him. The count was illegal because of the neutral corner rule. Walcott should never have stopped that fight in my opinion, although there is no doubt in my mind Ali would have won anyway.
I think Liston's explanation of being too afraid to get up could be the truth, or it could be an excuse. Who knows. It's just one of boxings great mysteries. I try not to lose sleep over it.
A 23 or 24 year old man beating a 37 year old man back then was no big deal. Sonny is listed as being born in 1932, but it is well known it was 1928 or 29. Sonny was way past his prime when they fought.
Yet one of his greatest victories was only 9 months before the Clay fight. He just met his match in a green, though stylistically difficult, match. Liston honks love to go on about how dangerous he was in the late 60's. And they are correct to some degree. However, he would have never been that dangerous to Clay/Ali. Styles make fights. And on the converse, some lesser fighters were more dangerous to Ali than Liston.
Of course Liston wasn't at his absolute peak for any of the fights, but the talk about him being shot is just bull. He looked very impressive in the fights just before, and went on fighting for about 4 years after the second defeat to Ali. I will never be satisfied with how either fight ended, but for me all the talk about fixes and Liston being shot is just excuses for Liston worshippers refusing to admit their hero just got his ass whopped.