I can't particularly give a rating. I hate lists. Yes, I typed it. A vehement hate for lists. They are the worst waste of time in this sport and on this board (most message boards suffer from this issue). I don't mind speculating the possibility of Floyd Mayweather vs. Sugar Ray Leonard and their conflicting styles, but lists? Lists? It's easy to sum it up if you're just talking about lists. We're sitting here, and I'm supposed to be an ESB classic member, and we're talking about lists? I mean look here, we're sitting here talking about lists, not a head-to-head, NOT a head-to-head, I repeat NOT A HEAD-TO-HEAD, but we're talking about lists! Not the head-to-head where we can match styles and talk seriously about tangible things like it's my last chance to explain it all, but we're talking about lists man. How silly is that?
TOP TEN PRE WORLD WAR TWO BANTAMWEIGHTS 01 - Terry McGovern 02 - George Dixon 03 - Manuel Ortiz 04 - Pete Herman 05 - Panama Al Brown 06 - Joe Lynch 07 - Sixto Escobar 08 - Charles Taylor 09 - Jimmy Barry 10 - Kid Williams
Lists are ridiculous, yes. But head-to-heads gets ridiculous too. Most of all I prefer learning new history. There are so many historical details out there to be discovered. Sometimes people here post some nice little article they've found. I appreciate things like that. :good
That's what I've been doing. I read loads of articles on lots of other websites. That and I've been taking advantage of my university library privileges to read about boxing in my "downtime". I'm currently trying to figure out about Gypsy Joe Harris, but the man is a mystery.
Lists are difficult, lets take the example of MW. Jones beats Hopkins easily, Hopkins would never beat that version of Jones but will always be rated above Jones because of his longevity/resume depth at the weight. Same with people rating Lamotta over Lloyd Marshall.
I did these in 2004/05: Top 30 who turned pro since 1976: 30 James Toney 29 Ronald 'Winky' Wright 28 Orlando Canizales 27 Mike Tyson 26 Sot Chitalada 25 Jeff Chandler 24 Lennox Lewis 23 Floyd Mayweather Jr 22 Aaron Pryor 21 Myung Woo Yuh 20 Jung Koo Chang 19 Kostya Tszyu 18 Brian Mitchell 17 Jeff Fenech 16 Salvador Sanchez 15 Marco Antonio Barrera 14 Mike McCallum 13 Felix Trinidad 12 Evander Holyfield 11 Khoasio Galaxy 10 Michael Spinks 9 Azumah Nelson 8 Bernard Hopkins 7 Ricardo Lopez 6 Roy Jones 5 Thomas Hearns 4 Pernell Whitaker 3 Oscar de la Hoya 2 Julio Cesar Chavez 1 Ray Leonard 35 great fighters 35 Roy Jones 34 George Foreman 33 Joe Gans 32 Ruben Olivares 31 Thomas Hearns 30 Marvin Hagler 29 Joe Louis 28 Gene Tunney 27 George Dixon 26 Eder Jofre 25 Carlos Zarate 24 Alexis Arguello 23 Pernell Whitaker 22 Oscar de la Hoya 21 Pancho Villa 20 Bob Fitzsimmons 19 Stanley Ketchel 18 Harry Grebb 17 Ezzard Charles 16 Benny Leonard 15 Julio Cesar Chavez 14 Mickey Walker 13 Ray Leonard 12 Carlos Monzon 11 Muhammad Ali 10 Charley Burley 9 Sammy Langford 8 Archie Moore 7 Jimmy Wilde 6 Willie Pep 5 Sandy Sadler 4 Georges Carpentier 3 Roberto Duran 2 Henry Armstrong 1 Ray Robinson Top 10 Mexicans 10 Erik Morales 9 Vicente Saldivar 8 Lupe Pintor 7 Salvador Sanchez 6 Marco Antonio Barrera 5 Jose Napoles (Adopted Mexico as his own country; Cuban by birth) 4 Ricardo Lopez 3 Ruben Olivares 2 Carlos Zarate 1 Julio Cesar Chavez Mentions to: Humberto Gonzales, Miguel Canto, Rodolfo Martinez, Alfonso Zamora, Daniel Zaragoza, Joe Rivers, Baby Arizmendi, Chalky Wright, Manuel Medina, Rafael Limon, Jose Luis Ramirez and Jose Luis Castillo. Lightweight 10 Sammy Angott 9 Julio Cesar Chavez 8 Bob Montgomery 7 Ike Williams 6 Battling Nelson 5 Joe Gans 4 Pernell Whitaker 3 Henry Armstrong 2 Benny Leonard 1 Roberto Duran Mentions: Jack McAuliffe, George Lavigne, Frank Erne, Tony Canzoneri, Barney Ross, Lou Ambers, Beau Jack, Jimmy Carter, Carlos Ortiz, Ken Buchanan, Esteban DeJesus, Guts Ishimatsu (Ishimatsu Suzuki), Alexis Arguello, Edwin Rosario, Jose Luis Ramirez, Hector Camacho Snr, Oscar de la Hoya, Shane Mosley, Steve Johnson, Jose Luis Castillo and Floyd Mayweather Jr
Top fighters of the 90's 100 Iran Barkley 99 Vassily Jirov 98 Jorge Castro 97 Joe Calzaghe 96 Meldrick Taylor 95 Vinny Pazienza 94 Simon Brown 93 Gianfranco Rosi 92 Frankie Liles 91 William Joppy 90 Ray Mercer 89 Dingaan Thobela 88 Crisanto Espana 87 Eloy Rojas 86 Robert Quiroga 85 Nana Yaw Konadu 84 Juan Martin Coggi 83 Orlin Norris 82 Ronald Wright 81 Kennedy McKinney 80 Tim Austin 79 Julio Cesar Vazquez 78 Steve Collins 77 Al Cole 76 Lorenzo Barber 75 James Douglas 74 James McGirt 73 Miguel Angel Gonzales 72 Tony Lopez 71 Sharmba Mitchell 70 Lonnie Bradley 69 Antonio Esparragoza 68 Jake Matlala 67 Mike Tyson 66 Fernando Vargas 65 Tommy Hearns 64 Wilfred Vazquez 63 Orzubek Nazarov 62 Dave McAuley 61 Arturo Gatti 60 Harry Simon 59 Joichiro Tatsuyuhi 58 Michael Moorer 57 Julian Jackson 56 Kevin Kelley 55 Sung Il Moon 54 John John Molina 53 Manuel Medina 52 Maurice Blocker 51 Daniel Zaragoza 50 John David Jackson 49 Reggie Johnson 48 Myung Woo Yuh 47 Zack Padilla 46 Jeff Fenech 45 George Foreman 44 Henry Maske 43 Genaro Hernandez 42 Ike Quartey 41 Johnny Tapia 40 Vuyani Bungu 39 Vitali Klitschko 38 Freddie Pendleton 37 Mike McCallum 36 Michael Carbajal 35 Mark Johnson 34 Humberto Gonzales 33 Frankie Randall 32 Steve Johnston 31 Junior Jones 30 Yuri Arbachakov 29 Erik Morales 28 Tom Johnson 27 Chris Eubank 26 Gerald McClellan 25 Virgil Hill 24 Nigel Benn 23 Saman Sorjaturong 22 Kostya Tszyu 21 Azumah Nelson 20 Floyd Mayweather Jr 19 Marco Antonio Barrera 18 Bernard Hopkins 17 Shane Mosley 16 Riddick Bowe 15 Brian Mitchell 14 Dariusz Michalczewski 13 Kaosai Galaxy 12 Orlando Canizales 11 Lennox Lewis 10 Julio Cesar Chavez 9 James Toney 8 Felix Trinidad 7 Naseem Hamed 6 Terry Norris 5 Pernell Whitaker 4 Evander Holyfield 3 Ricardo Lopez 2 Roy Jones Jr 1 Oscar de la Hoya
Top 101 of the 80's 101 Herol Graham 100 Miguel Lora 99 Michael Moorer 98 Hilmer Kenty 97 Rolando Navarrete 96 Yong Kang Kim 95 Gabby Canizales 94 Fulgencio Obelmejias 93 Bobby Czyz 92 Frank Tate 91 Matthew Hilton 90 Sean O'Grady 89 Terry Marsh 88 Greg Haugen 87 Duke McKenzie 86 Jorge Paez 85 Wilfred Gomez 84 Maurice Hope 83 Elly Pical 82 Saoul Mamby 81 John Mugabi 80 Eddie Mustafa Muhammad 79 Milton McCrory 78 Cornelius Boza-Edwards 77 Rafael Limon 76 Sam Serrano 75 Dave McAuley 74 Livingstone Bramble 73 Dennis Andries 72 Juan Martin Coggi 71 Sung Il Moon 70 Tony Tucker 69 Marvin Johnson 68 Gianfranco Rosi 67 Jim Watt 66 Bobby Chacon 65 Jiro Watanabe 64 Fidel Bassa 63 Seung Hoon Lee 62 Alan Minter 61 Ray Mancini 60 Dodie Penalosa 59 Juan LaPorte 58 Simon Brown 57 Ayub Kalule 56 Iran Barkley 55 Chong Pal Park 54 Carlos Deleon 53 Rocky Lockbridge 52 Barry McGuigan 51 Mark Breland 50 Charles Williams 49 Sambu Kalambay 48 Humberto Gonzales 47 Julian Jackson 46 Lloyd Honeyghan 45 Raul Perez 44 Jose Luis Ramirez 43 James McGirt 42 Tim Whitherspoon 41 Marlon Starling 40 Hilario Zapata 39 Orlando Canizales 38 Virgil Hill 37 Roger Mayweather 36 Edwin Rosario 35 Daniel Zaragoza 34 Wilfred Benitez 33 Antonio Esparragoza 32 Mathew Saad Muhammad 31 Santos Laciar 30 Meldrick Taylor 29 Dwight Muhammad Qawi 28 Gilberto Roman 27 Don Curry 26 Brian Mitchell 25 Alexis Arguello 24 Hector Camacho 23 Lupe Pintor 22 Sot Chitalada 21 Michael Nunn 20 Jeff Fenech 19 Myung Woo Yuh 18 Jung Koo Chang 17 Mike McCallum 16 Evander Holyfield 15 Pernell Whitaker 14 Jeff Chandler 13 Khoasio Galaxy 12 Salvador Sanchez 11 Azumah Nelson 10 Roberto Duran 9 Aaron Pryor 8 Eusebio Pedroza 7 Julio Cesar Chavez 6 Larry Holmes 5 Michael Spinks 4 Tommy Hearns 3 Mike Tyson 2 Marvin Hagler 1 Ray Leonard
Top 40 Heavies 40: Cleveland Williams 39: Zora Foley 38: Tommy Burns 37: Michael Spinks 36: James Douglas 35: James Braddock 34: George Godfrey 33: Jimmy Bivens 32: Max Baer 31: Jerry Quarry 30: Tim Whitherspoon 29: Bob Fitzsimmons 28: Jack Sharkey 27: Sam McVey 26: Joe Jeanette 25: Vitali Klitschko 24: Peter Jackson 23: Ken Norton 22: Joe Walcott (Jersey) 21: Gene Tunney 20: Riddick Bowe 19: Floyd Patterson 18: Max Schmeling 17: Ezzard Charles 16: Sammy Langford 15: Harry Wills 14: James Corbett 13: Sonny Liston 12: Joe Frazier 11: Mike Tyson 10: Lennox Lewis 9 James Jeffries 8: Jack Dempsey 7: Rocky Marciano 6: Evander Holyfield 5: Larry Holmes 4: Jack Johnson 3: George Foreman 2: Joe Louis 1: Muhammad Ali Top 10 lightweights 10 Sammy Angott 9 Julio Cesar Chavez 8 Bob Montgomery 7 Ike Williams 6 Battling Nelson 5 Joe Gans 4 Pernell Whitaker 3 Henry Armstrong 2 Benny Leonard 1 Roberto Duran Mentions: Jack McAuliffe, George Lavigne, Frank Erne, Tony Canzoneri, Barney Ross, Lou Ambers, Beau Jack, Jimmy Carter, Carlos Ortiz, Ken Buchanan, Esteban DeJesus, Guts Ishimatsu (Ishimatsu Suzuki), Alexis Arguello, Edwin Rosario, Jose Luis Ramirez, Hector Camacho Snr, Oscar de la Hoya, Shane Mosley, Steve Johnson, Jose Luis Castillo and Floyd Mayweather Jr Top 10 feathers The Featherweights are an incredibly talented group of fighters; my all-time list goes: 10: Salvador Sanchez 9: Joey Archibald 8: Azumah Nelson 7: Johnny Kilbane 6: George Dixon 5: Henry Armstrong 4; Eusebio Pedroza 3: Abe Attell 2: Willie Pep 1: Sandy Saddler Honorary mentions: Young Griffo, Terry McGovern, Jim Driscoll, Bat Battalino, Hogan 'Kid' Bassey, Davey Moore, Sugar Ramos, Vicente Saldivar, Eder Jofre, Antonio Esparragoza, Naseem Hamed and Marco Antonio Barrera Mentions: Ben Jordan, Young Corbett II, Johnny Dundee, Kid Kaplan, Tony Canzoneri, Kid Chocolate, Baby Arizmendi, Chalky Wright, Howard Winstone, Alexis Arguello, Danny Lopez, Juan LaPorte, Jeff Fenech, Marcos Villasana, Tom Johnson, Kevin Kelley, Eloy Rojas, Manuel Medina, Wilfred Vazquez, Erik Morales, and Manny Pacquiao