Pretend that you can magically bring the Louis just before fighting Schmeling the 2nd time and the Tyson just before fighting Biggs to 2009. Allow one week for them to study each other and adapt to modern boxing. What would the outcome be in 10 fights? I prefer to leave out the factor of them learning from mistakes of their previous fight, so let's assume that they have any knowledge of their previous fight erased from their memories.
After about five fights they would both be broken down old men. Louis would do better as the series progresed.
Call me crazy, but I have watched just about every former champion in some way on tape, and I dont see any one of them I would favor over the best Tyson. He was just too fast too explosive and too hard to hit cleanly at his best. That doesnt mean Tyson wins every time, but I would favor him over anyone.
I don't think Lewis had a bad chin by any means.....but him being K.O'd near his Prime (whereas Ali and Holmes recovered and went on to win when they were decked) makes me think he might not last. Hope all that makes sense :good
I dont think that Holmes would ever have beaten Tyson to be honest. Not mobile enough. Toget onto the subject of the thread I would pick Louis on the basis that he is more likley to deliver when the chips are down.
i think Louis can win this fight but it needs to be a 15 rounder i dont think he can win a 12 rounder he has to cover up from Tysons early 4 round assualt then he can outbox him and outfight him in the later rounds as Tyson aint so good in the later rounds but i think Tyson would floor him in the first 4 and win them so big he wins a 12 rounder on the 10 point must system but in a 15 rounder oon a rounds basis Louis wins convincly
For all of louis punching power and hand speed he was quite fragile. His chin was only c-grade and he wouldn't be able to take too many of tysons blows. He was also slow of foot so he wouldn't be able to move away from tyson once hurt. Combine this with the fact that louis was no defensive wizard and it spells a short night for the "brown bomber".
I don't see Louis winning. His durability wasn't a problem but it wasn't his strong point either, I see Tyson getting the better of the exchanges due to his superior power, speed, and chin and winning by a KO in about 6. Great fight though and like some people have already said, Louis was better the more times he fought you. In a series, him winning a fight isn't far fetched.