maidana is a very average fighter and most guys at 147 would beat him

Opposition at 140:
L SD12 Andrey Kotelnik for Kotelnik's WBA belt
W TKO6 Victor Ortiz
W KO6 Victor Cayo
W UD12 DeMarcus Corley
L UD12 Amir Khan for Khan's WBA belt
W MD12 Erik Morales
W KO4 Petr Petrov for vacant WBA belt
Opposition at 147:
L UD10 Devon Alexander
W TKO8 Jesus Soto Karass
W TKO6 Josesito Lopez
W UD12 Adrien Broner for Broner's WBA belt

Pretty solid resume indeed.

I'm not sure who these "most guys at 147" are who you think "would beat him."

 

They're both crap fights and both are no hopers

If Floyd had any semblance of shame or balls to back up his ¨im the GOAT¨ bull**** claims he would have tried to mke a fight with any of the following

Pac at 147
GGG or Lara at 154

Those three are legitimate threats (something Floyd actively avoids)

Other fighters that would be better opponents than crude Maidana and glass jawed Khan

Bradley
Thurman
Provo
Mathysse
Danny Garcia
etc

 

I have no dog in the Mayweather-Pacquiao debate but Mayweather has no room to criticise Pacquiao for fighting Brandon Rios when he's fighting equally as limited Maidana.

 

atsch :verysad

 

he is no matthyse? ok wel just so we are clear he is 1 division higher then matthyse and he has beaten him twice in the amateurs...

 

Are you serious? How the hell can you put Maidana and Rios in the same sentence when Maidana has accomplished way more in his career then Rios.:huh Rios lost his last fight at 140 to Mike Alvarado and then Manny wanted to fight him at 147 knowing what the outcome is going to be. Maidana is a champion that is more than what Rios was when he fought Pac. So Mayweather does have room to criticise.

 

the same madona who went life and death with granpa morales?

concaine's leftover?

whose biggest win was against a guy malignaggi easily outboxed?

that madona?

at 147, madona, rios, alvarado, ruslan, guerrrero, peterson, ortiz, alexander: they are same level in my book, with berto/broner slightly below and bradley above, meaning he will be favorite against anyone.

id put concaine there too, just bec he beat madona even if he hast fought at ww.

marquez, though he hasnt put anyone outside of bradley and pac, id say he is slightly above the pack.

 

Maidana lost every round to Average Alexander for crying out loud. Both him and Rios are slow limited plodders with little in the way of boxing skills

 

lopetego, log the hell off and go and study your boxing history. your knowledge is useless dude!!

 

Yet somehow he is ranked in the top 10 at WW by several publications. Strange.

 

He is ranked top 10 by every publication i would think seeing that he has a title?.

 

Didn't a slow plodder gatekeeper almost knockout Keith Thurman, the savior of the welterwight division?

 

DA said he was easy work

 

DA , the guy that kotelnik schooled in his own backyard? The same DA that quit against Bradley? Oh that guy.

 

"equally as limited" in boxing style.

Far superior in actual boxing skills.