Maidana isn't even a Top 10 Welter...

Again I will repeat. Stop with your low quality troll threads.

Khan hasn't beat anyone at 147 yet (although his Collazo win does boost him above lame ass Brook)
Thurman hasn't beat anyone at 147 yet
Brook has barely beat anyone at world level!

"Devon SCHOOLED Maidana so IMO Maidana HAS to be rated below Alexander." - Then why have you rated Pac above Marquez.


1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Tim Bradley
4. Juan Manuel Marquez (Just picking his fights till retirement he did ok against Bradley though so meh)
5. Marcos Maidana
6. Shawn Porter
7. Devon Alexander

tight between the bottom 3...they lose and win against different fighters.

 

I have him at #8, above Brook & Guerrero, below Alexander.

 

PAC beat Marquez 3 times

Khan owned maidana

Maidan as only win is over duck weather

 

my god.

"Maidana isn't even a Top 10 Welter"

/close thread.

That **** doesn't even need explaining unless you're ******ed or don't know ANYTHING about boxing.

 

Pacquiao
Mayweather
Bradley
JMM
Porter
Khan
Alexander
------------------
Maidana
Thurman
Abregu
Brook

Head to head, I would take Abregu over Maidana. Thurman too. Alexander schools Maidana again. Guerrero hasn't done sh*t to be ranked in the top 10, or top 11.

I'd take Maidana to beat Brook, who just can't handle good pressure fighters.

 

No matter how to try to constrew it Maidana is currently above Khan and Alexander in the WW rankings

 

So, he kicked Floyd's ass but isn't a Top 10 Welter? atsch

 

1.Floyd
2.Pac
3.Bradley
4.JMM
5.Chino
6.Porter
7.Thurman
8.Khan
9.Guerrero
10.Alexander

That's accurate.

Thurman hasn't beaten anyone.
Guerrero has been inactive.
Alexander has sucked.
Khan has 1 fight at 147 against a decent opponent.
Porter's best win is a faded Paulie
Chino has a good win in Broner, and did well against the best fighter in the world. That ups his stock to me.
Pac is self explanatory
Bradley is self explanatory.
JMM is self explanatory.

My grandmother has a better resume at 147 then Brook.

Floyd is the king. Nuff said.

 

What has Khan done at 47 to be above Chino, as well as Alexander, Porter? Nothing. He's either 6 or 5. Meaning just behind porter, or just ahead of him.

 

No there's only one king of the world.

But Khan almost got stopped in the 10th round. And Chino has improved since then under Garcia. Better Jab, Accuracy and Stamina.

Khan has regressed since than. In my opinion, he was really good at 140.

 

I'm a fan of Alexander and have Maidana ahead of him, Maidana losing to Khan/Alexander doesn't rate them ahead at WW, Maidana would be widely favored to win a rematch vs Khan and almost KO'd him in their first fight, Alexander since beating Maidana beat Purdy, Baily & lost to Porter Maidana since has beaten Karass, Lopez, Broner & a close in some opinions loss to Mayweather which put him ahead by recent performance and comp.

Marquez is another fighter I like but he is 2-3 @ 147, Porter is debatable with Maidana all depends on how high you rate the Alexander win just based off WW resume Maidana should be top 3/4. I'm pretty sure R.Duran has losses to Leonard, Hearns, & Hagler yet is rated above all three all time