Malignanni vs Gatti both in prime who wins?

paulie on cuts/bruising

 

paulie wins by brutal ko

 

Good fight. I can't pick a winner.

 

I think Malignaggi would have similar success that Ivan Robinson had against Gatti. It would be a great fight but Malignaggi won't get hit as much as Robinson but his punches wouldn have less effect obviously. I Gatti getting cut to shreds by Malognaggi's jab and quick quick combos.

 

Malgignaji UD

 

Gatti was a better fighter, especially under Buddy McGirt.

 

Gatti is far more accomplished, in a deeper era, and is the better fighter.

I would pick also Ivan Robinson to school Malignaggi.

 

Well, are you then saying that Gatti's prime was at junior WW?

Otherwise, once again, this fight is stupid to talk about. Most people say Gatti's prime was 130 or 135. They were prime in two separate divisions unless you think Gatti was prime at 140 (which believe it or not I do think a good case could be made for it).

 

gatti by referee stoppage.

 

gatti by tko

 

gatti was even the more skilled boxer when he wanted to be. he just would go ape **** all the time and want to brawl

 

Paulie by cool head and sublime boxing skills.

 

You guys gotta realize how tough Paulie is. He went twelve rounds with a broken jaw against a prime Miguel Cotto, and you guys think Gatti would KO/stop him?

Gatti gets flustered by movement and isn't the best at cutting the ring off.

Paulie by competitive UD.