Manny Pacquiao and Mayweather: who defeats them from 130-140???

you would ****ing know

 

Put the pipe out or log off.

 

You are just being generationally biased on some of your assumptions.

 

the pac with a right hook?...the one that blasted hatton in two??

i dont think so....



mayweather will be unbeaten in any era....as he ducks every threat around....

 

The classicos don't like Pac cause they weren't able to realise how good he was when he first burst onto the scene. Now they wanna try to justify their mistake but the next generation of classicos will probably laugh at them.

 

Very respectul list but I think Floyd matches up much better...bigger and much better defense...:good

 

I recognize that he is the best in the world Philla...just not on the level you talkin about...but there is no doubt in my mind that Manny is the best in the world today...he not no top 10 atg or no **** like that though...

 

last i checked he is fighting shane who is the biggest threat at ww imo...physically and tactically this will be floyds hardest fight...paul williams could be a hard one too but only from a tacticul look...physically i dont think floyd would get hit as much against paul as he will against shane...pac mos def is not a hard as a fight as shane

 

absolutely. Whittaker, Pac and Mayweather are all legends in their own rights and people are allowing rose tinted glasses of some past fighters to ignore that tghese guys would win a lot of fights against their fellow greats at 130-140.

certainly, PBF's technical abilities would give him a chance against anyone. the early 1970s version of Duran, for example, if you've read Hands of Stone shows you that his team might well have avoided a good technical fighter like PBF.

 

and in this weight range Mosley was genuinely a great, look at the brilliance and effectiveness of his style rather than CV. Not at welter and light middle as some might argue - though Mosley huggers are a little like Holmes lovers, they get a free pass due to the respect their fighters naturally command.

 

Mayweather is a better fighter than Pac at 130 and 135. Oddly the gap closes as the weight goes up because Mayweather loses some steam on his punches and some of his speed, while Pac seems to gain both.

 

Thinking about it, you've got a good point there.

 

Henry armstrong would not beat floyd, not a chance. Floyd has a good chance against anyone head to head at those weights.

 

Pac would lose to all of them as Pac doesn't win any fantasy fight.