Pacquiao wins this by easy and brutal KO. Donaire single elite win against Darchinyan isn't enough to prove he's better than Manny. Manny has done much more.
Manny was very raw at 112. I'd probably favor Donaire but Pacquiao's straight left always had the potential to end fights at that weight at any time.
Hm I just noticed the weight. Well, I don't think Pacquiao can make that weight anymore, so I won't say anything. But if I had to compare with Pacquiao when he was at flyweight then I would say Pacquiao.
yeah but Manny wasn't nearly as good at 112 as he is now. He was a completely different fighter who was one handed with a lot of flaws. His last fight at 112 was in 1999 and he got KO'd.
Pac would probably win, but his achievemnts in that division really aren't that good. He wasn't the beast he is today. It would be a close fight.
If it was PAC who was at 112 then yea....I could see Nonito winning but if its THIS version of PAC at 112 Nonito would be hurt very badly.
pac was still waaaaayyy too green to **** with someone with the level of skill that donaire posesses. you're pitting the young pacquiao against a p4p-level fighter.
Manny was only 18 when he was at that weight.... not to mention most of the time he's a head hunter. Hard to say.